Charly Triballeau/AFP via Getty Images
THE way NOT MY pres drumpf / trump, NOT MY vp vance and the neo-nazi fascist fotze trunt pigs in their administration have slurred and demonized Renee Nicole Good and others murdered by the ice-hsi-cbp gestapo, the way Americans exercising their constitutional rights are being physically attacked and verbally maligned and condemned by this government and it's right wing ass licking sycophants is disgusting. This administration's immorality and illegal actions has eliminated it's legitimacy from all except the voluntarily ignorant and those whose greed is being satisfied. This from PBS NewsHour and NPR....
MINNESOTA LEADERS AND PROTESTERS PUSH FOR ACCOUNTABILITY AFTER ICE SHOOTING
There are protests in Minnesota against ICE and the killing of 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good. Local officials, including Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, are hammering ICE and its aggressive presence in the community. State officials also said that federal investigators were shutting them out of the inquiry and blocking them from accessing evidence. Fred de Sam Lazaro reports from Minneapolis.
Read the Full Transcript
Notice: Transcripts are machine and human generated and lightly edited for accuracy. They may contain errors.
Geoff Bennett:
Welcome to the "News Hour."
There were protests in Minnesota today over ICE and the fatal shooting of a 37-year-old woman, Renee Nicole Good, on Wednesday, while, at the White House, Vice President J.D. Vance strongly defended ICE, saying the officer was defending himself and called Good's death a tragedy of her own making.
Amna Nawaz:
Local officials, including Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, are hammering ICE and its aggressive presence in the community. State officials also said that federal investigators were effectively shutting them out of the shooting inquiry and blocking them from accessing evidence.
Many in the community were reeling from the events of the past 48 hours.
Special correspondent Fred de Sam Lazaro has the story from Minneapolis.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
This morning, protesters clashed with federal agents in front of the Whipple Federal Building outside of Minneapolis, a city on edge after an ICE agent fatally shot U.S. citizen Renee Nicole Good yesterday.
The shooting, caught on camera by bystanders, shows a chaotic scene on the residential street, ending with an agent firing three shots into Good's SUV.
Woman:
No! No! Shame! Shame!
(Gunshots)
Woman:
Oh, my (expletive deleted) God. What the (expletive deleted)?
J.D. Vance, Vice President of the United States: This was an attack on law and order.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
At a press conference this afternoon, Vice President J.D. Vance reiterated the administration's defense of the agent's actions.
J.D. Vance:
What I am certain of is that she violated the law. What I am certain of is that officer had every reason to think that he was under very serious threat for injury or in fact his life. What I am certain of is that she accelerated in a way where she ran into the guy. I don't know what was in her heart and what was in her head, but I know that she violated the law and I know that officer was acting in self-defense.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
But state and local officials sharply disagree about what the video evidence shows. They say Good was trying to get away from ICE, not to run down the officer.
Vance says, ultimately, the blame falls on what he calls the far left.
J.D. Vance:
I can believe that her death is a tragedy while also recognizing that it's a tragedy of her own making and a tragedy of the far left, who has marshaled an entire movement, a lunatic fringe, against our law enforcement officers.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
The officer, who local media identified as Jonathan Ross, is described as having 10 years of experience with the force and was involved in a separate incident in which he was dragged by a car and deployed a Taser, according to a criminal complaint from June of last year.
Dieu Do is an activist with the Minnesota Immigrant Rights Action Committee.
Dieu Do, Minnesota Immigrant Rights Action Committee:
To hear Kristi Noem and other federal leaders not show any empathy, but to start a smear campaign against Renee and Minnesotans, is abhorrent and disgusting.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
A vigil and a makeshift memorial grew Wednesday evening near the site of the shooting, honoring Good, whose family and friends describe her as a Christian who participated in mission trips, a poet who loved to sing, and a loving mother of three.
At the memorial today, where protesters have put up makeshift barricades, Somali immigrant Deqa Adan came to pay her respects.
Deqa Adan, Minnesota Resident:
If you see a kid being bullied, you stand up for them. You say something. Renee did that. She stood up. She stood up for the rights for people being captured in the streets like herd of animals, and she lost her life because of that.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz urged accountability for Good's death.
Gov. Tim Walz (D-MN):
People in positions of power have already passed judgment. From the president, to the vice president to Kristi Noem have stood and told you things that are verifiably false, verifiably inaccurate.
It feels to me like we're at one of those inflection points, that simply asking our government to give us accountability, listen to local leaders, ratchet down the rhetoric, let people feel safe in their person, and let's let our kids go to school without fear.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
Minneapolis schools were closed today in the wake of the shooting and after immigration agents clashed with people near one high school yesterday afternoon.
For now, the city, no stranger to civil unrest, anxiously awaits what's to come while mourning one of its own.
Dieu Do:
The place that Renee was killed yesterday was six blocks away from where George Floyd was murdered. The law enforcement response is the same, to lie, to cover up and to spin a different story on really what actually happened.
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
As of late this afternoon, a GoFundMe campaign set up for Renee Good has raised close to $900,000 -- Geoff.
Geoff Bennett:
And, Fred, what more have you seen on the streets and heard as you have talked to people there?
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
Geoff, anywhere you go in this city, there is palpable tension and a sense of deja vu. I'm standing near the site of yesterday's incident, and it's not far from where George Floyd was murdered.
One person here, however, told me that, unlike George Floyd, which was a one-off, this seems unrelenting. The federal enforcement surge began several days ago, and it is targeting not just immigration enforcement or immigration, but, rather, also the expanding fraud investigation involving Minnesota state programs, which the administration has vowed to crack down on and which targets specifically the Somali immigrant community in this city.
Geoff Bennett:
We know the mayor and other Democrats are urging ICE to leave this city. Based on your reporting, what's expected of the immigration enforcement effort in the days ahead?
Fred de Sam Lazaro:
If anything, Geoff, word is that they are going to escalate. The man in charge of Border Patrol, Greg Bovino, has been sighted in several locations in this city. More officers are being dispatched here, so there's no sense that it's going to diminish in any way.
For their part, the protesters say they do not plan to let up in any of their activities and their vigilance. We take winter in our stride here in Minnesota, but this one is one that is not going to be forgotten soon.
Geoff Bennett:
Fred de Sam Lazaro in Minneapolis for us tonight.
Fred, our thanks to you.
Fred de Sam Lazaro is director of the Under-Told Stories Project at the University of St. Thomas in Minnesota, a program that combines international journalism and teaching. He has served with the PBS NewsHour since 1985 and is a regular contributor and substitute anchor for PBS' Religion and Ethics Newsweekly.
Frank Carlson is the Senior Coordinating Producer for America at a Crossroads. He's been making video at the NewsHour since 2010.
Related
What we know one day after the killing of Renee Good by an ICE agent in Minneapolis
The killing of Renee Nicole Good by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer inspired a vigil Wednesday night, and it's sparking protests in Minneapolis and elsewhere on Thursday. Reactions to the shooting reflect outrage over Good's death and a deep divide in how it's portrayed — as either a tragic abuse of power or an officer acting in self-defense.
NPR identified the ICE agent who fired the gun as Jonathan Ross by cross-referencing court records with details about the officer released by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem at a Wednesday news conference. Noem — without naming the officer — said he had been in a previous confrontation with a protester.
"The very same officer who was attacked today had previously been dragged by an anti-ICE rioter who had rammed him with a car and [dragged] him back in June. He sustained injuries at that time, as well," she said.
The description of the incident matches a court case against a Mexican national, Roberto Carlos Munoz-Guatemala, who was found guilty in December of assaulting a federal officer in Bloomington, Minn. DHS confirmed to NPR that is the court case that Noem referenced. Ross' name is mentioned in the court documents for the case. According to court records, federal officers attempting to arrest Munoz-Guatemala, who had been convicted of sexual abuse, pulled him over in his car. Munoz-Guatemala sped away after Ross had reached inside the vehicle, trapping the agent's arm and causing him to sustain injuries to his arm and hand.
Noem said that Wednesday's shooting occurred after protesters in Minneapolis harassed and impeded ICE agents and that the officer acted to protect himself and fellow officers. She alleged that Good's actions amounted to "an act of domestic terrorism."
Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison told NPR's Morning Edition that he disagrees with Noem's characterization of Good as a domestic terrorist.
"She was a compassionate neighbor trying to be a legal observer on behalf of her immigrant neighbors," Ellison said. "That's what she was doing at the moment of her death. And she was a poet. She was a mom. She was a daughter. And I am deeply saddened by what happened to her and her family."
2 people wounded in a shooting involving Border Patrol agents in Portland, Ore.
As Minneapolis continued to grapple with the fatal shooting, police in Portland, Ore., said two people were injured in a shooting by federal agents.
Around 2:15 p.m. local time on Thursday, a man and a woman were shot by federal agents in East Portland, according to the Portland Police Bureau. FBI Portland told member station OPB that U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents were involved. The two people wounded were taken to a local hospital. Their conditions were unknown.
"We are still in the early stages of this incident," said Portland Police Chief Bob Day in a press release. "We understand the heightened emotion and tension many are feeling in the wake of the shooting in Minneapolis, but I am asking the community to remain calm as we work to learn more."
Tricia McLaughlin, a spokeswoman for the Department of Homeland Security, said the shooting occurred while Border Patrol agents were conducting a "targeted vehicle stop." McLaughlin asserted that the driver "weaponized his vehicle and attempted to run over the law enforcement agents" after agents identified themselves. McLaughlin said the driver and passenger were affiliated with the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua but did not offer evidence of their gang association.
"Fearing for his life and safety, an agent fired a defensive shot. The driver drove off with the passenger, fleeing the scene," she said in a statement. "This situation is evolving, and more information is forthcoming."
Competing narratives quickly emerge
Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey and other local officials have dismissed Noem's version of events as political spin. At a news conference on Wednesday, Frey said of the self-defense explanation, "Having seen the video myself, I want to tell everybody that is bull****. "
"This was a federal agent recklessly using power that resulted in somebody dying," Frey said, adding that he wants ICE units to leave Minneapolis.
Scott Olson/Getty ImagesMinnesota Gov. Tim Walz said he was angered by the killing, which he linked to President Trump's policy of sending ICE and other federal agents surging into cities such as Minneapolis.
"What we're seeing is the consequences of governance designed to generate fear, headlines and conflict," Walz said on Wednesday. "It's governing by reality TV and today that recklessness cost someone their life."
Noem said on Wednesday that she had spoken with Walz about the killing, but added that they don't agree on whether it was justified: "We have two very different viewpoints on what happened."
Hours after the shooting, Noem defended the ICE officer who shot Good, saying the woman had blocked federal officers with her SUV and disobeyed orders to get out of her vehicle.
"It's clearly established law that a vehicle driven by a person and used to harm someone is a deadly weapon," she said, as NPR reported. "Deadly force is perfectly lawful when a threat is faced by a weapon, so I do believe that this officer used his training in this situation."
When Noem was asked on Thursday whether the officer remains on field duty, Noem said he had gone to a hospital for treatment, but was then released "and is spending time with his family now."
Noem also said the federal surge in Minneapolis will continue, and could even grow.
"We've got thousands of officers there," she said, "and I'm not opposed to sending more if necessary to keep people safe."
Key details of a controversial shooting
Here is a brief overview of what we know so far about the events leading to Good's death:
When: Police officers responded to reports of shots fired just after 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, according to a timeline published by the city of Minneapolis.
"Minneapolis firefighters then removed the 37-year-old victim from the vehicle and immediately began lifesaving measures until paramedics could respond," the city's account states. "She was transported to Hennepin County Medical Center, where she later died."
Where: Good was shot in her car on Portland Avenue, near East 34th Street, in a residential area a few blocks north of where police killed George Floyd in May 2020.
ICE agents at the scene were trying to deal with a vehicle that had gotten stuck in the snow, Noem said on Wednesday. As other ICE vehicles arrived, so did protesters, a witness named Caitlin Callenson told member station MPR.
How: Callenson, who recorded a video of the incident, told MPR that agents gave Good conflicting orders: One agent told her to drive away while another told her to get out of her SUV, Callenson said.
(Warning: The video at the following link includes violent actions and profanity.)
Video footage from the scene shows Good's Honda Pilot SUV sitting sideways on a snowy street, with her driver's side window down. Two uniformed officers approach the vehicle from the left. As one officer grabs at her door handle, a third officer who had circled to the front of the SUV from the opposite side draws his gun. As Good begins to drive away, the officer fires into her car.
"The preliminary information that we have indicates that this woman was in her vehicle and was blocking the roadway," Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O'Hara said at a news conference Wednesday. "At some point, a federal law enforcement officer approached her on foot and the vehicle began to drive off. At least two shots were fired. The vehicle then crashed on the side of the roadway."
What's next: On Wednesday, O'Hara said the FBI and Minnesota's state agency, the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, would jointly investigate the fatal shooting.
But in a statement Thursday, the BCA said that the U.S. Attorney's Office reversed course at the federal level, and the FBI alone would lead the investigation, as MPR reports. The BCA said it "has reluctantly withdrawn" from the process, because it would no longer have access to case materials and evidence.
Ellison, Minnesota's attorney general, said that he believes the FBI should not be involved in the inquiry.
"I know that ICE and FBI are different agencies," Ellison said, "but I think in order for public confidence to be at its best, there is some legitimate question as to what the role the FBI should be playing."
NPR's Ximena Bustillo contributed reporting.
No comments:
Post a Comment