90,000 deaths by October & How Nursing Homes Got Away With Hiding Bodies During the COVID-19 Outbreak 3&1JUL20

PHYSICAL DISTANCING: SIX FEET APART IS BETTER THAN SIX FEET UNDER!

Coronavirus Updates

THE PRC CORONAVIRUS FLAG IS A REMINDER OF THE PRC GOVERNMENT WHO UNLEASHED THIS PANDEMIC ON THE REST OF THE WORLD

CORONAVIRUS DASHBOARD

ONGOING reporting by the ACLU of the results of the drumpf / trump-pence administration's lack of planning for and lack of action to the coronavirus Covid-19 pandemic focused on those with disabilities and those in nursing homes and their care givers. The first part of these sieries of reports is here.....

90,000 deaths by October

We want to inform you of a growing crisis in our country that has largely continued out of sight.

To date, deaths in nursing homes and other congregate settings for people with disabilities account for nearly half of all COVID-19 deaths in the U.S. These are deaths to residents – people with disabilities – and staff – who are disproportionately people of color.

If current trends hold, nearly 90,000 people living in these facilities could die by October 1. Read more on our analysis of this grim crisis here.

These high death rates are not a coincidence or "inevitable" as many claim. They're the result of a system of discrimination and de-prioritization of people with disabilities that existed long before COVID-19.

Here's what we can tell you: After the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) declared a public health emergency, four months passed before it started to require nursing homes to publicly report COVID-19 infection and death rates. HHS still does not require other congregate settings, including institutions for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities and psychiatric facilities, to report deaths.

This lack of transparency doesn't just leave us without complete data to help control the pandemic – it allows lives to be lost without our knowing. In some cases, facilities have actively hidden deaths.

It's unacceptable. The ACLU has filed a petition with the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and disability rights organizations calling on HHS and its agencies to meet its obligations under federal law – including providing true transparency to who is living, working, and dying in these institutions. But we all must do more to bring this issue to the forefront.

Please learn more on the urgency of this discriminatory crisis during COVID-19 and the importance of demanding the truth from HHS now.

Thanks for reading,

Brooke Madubuonwu
Director of Legal Analytics & Quantitative Research, ACLU

How Nursing Homes Got Away With Hiding Bodies During the COVID-19 Outbreak

Brooke Madubuonwu , Director of Legal Analytics and Quantitative Research

Charlotte Lawrence , Special Assistant for Digital, Tech, and Analytics

July 1, 2020

When COVID-19 first reached the U.S., the epicenter was a single nursing home in Washington State, where 45 people died. That nursing home outbreak was a precursor of what was to come. Ever since, the virus has been devastating nursing homes across the country, due in part to systemic mismanagement and discrimination against the people who live and work inside.

To date, deaths in nursing homes and other congregate care facilities account for almost half of all COVID-19 deaths in the country, despite these groups making up less than 1 percent of the population. Residents of these congregate facilities are dying from COVID-19 at 8.6 times the rate of the overall 75+ population.
 
If current trends hold, that means nearly 90,000 people living in nursing homes and other congregate care settings could die by October 1.

Grim as this projection is, the actual death toll to date is likely much higher than currently reported. It took the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) months after declaring COVID-19 a national emergency to start requiring nursing homes to report deaths and infections despite ample evidence that these facilities were at high risk. Even now, nursing homes are only required to report data from May 8 onward. HHS doesn’t require other congregate settings for people with disabilities, such as psychiatric homes, to report at all. This lack of transparency, in addition to the government’s systemic mismanagement of nursing homes and other congregate settings, has helped create the crisis we see today.

In some cases, facilities have not only failed to report, but have actively hidden deaths from residents, families, and the government. For example, a nursing home in the Harlem neighborhood of New York City hid 26 COVID-related deaths from the state by covertly shipping bodies out of the facility. At a nursing home in New Jersey, 17 bodies were packed into a shed and later crowded into a morgue meant to house only four bodies. Other stories emerged of residents’ families being left in the dark about whether loved ones were dead or alive.
 
While HHS has lagged in collecting data, states can independently choose to require reporting and publicize this information. But too often, states are slow to report, and the data is often piecemeal and insufficient for analyzing the full scale of the pandemic.

As of June 29, only 41 states report deaths in nursing homes, and the level of detail varies from state to state. Some states offer only state or county totals (such as Arkansas, Indiana, Vermont, and others) while others break down data by facility (including North Carolina, West Virginia, and Nevada). Only 12 states go as far as naming facilities, reporting both cases and deaths, and disaggregating between residents and staff. Disaggregating data in this manner allows us to more accurately measure the impact on various groups of people. Residents are mostly seniors and all are people with disabilities. Staff are disproportionately people of color, women, and low-income. All of these demographic variables are relevant and integral to any adequate public health response.  

Even when states do report deaths and infections in nursing homes, most do not offer critical demographic data. This information is essential for assessing the impact of COVID-19 on different communities and demographic groups and facilitating our response. Yet only two states — Mississippi and Iowa — report the demographics of residents or staff who have tested positive or died.

People with disabilities and the people who work with them deserve to be counted. States can and should modify current policies to collect and publicize vital data while maintaining privacy standards. Last week, the ACLU filed a petition calling on HHS to do its job to address this crisis — and its job includes collecting and reporting full data from facilities that receive Medicaid or Medicare dollars.

The government needs good data to adequately respond to COVID-19. Data helps to inform where to investigate, where to channel resources, and what policies and practices to adopt. At the individual level, data helps people decide which facilities to live in and which to avoid. And in the long run, data can propel change to ensure this crisis never happens again.
 
The first step to change the system is to get to the truth. HHS must tell the truth about what is happening in the nursing homes and other congregate settings for people with disabilities that it oversees and funds with our taxpayer dollars.

Maps reflect public data reporting as of 06/29/2020. Links to state-level data sources available here.