NORTON META TAG

Showing posts with label contraception. Show all posts
Showing posts with label contraception. Show all posts

18 February 2016

Pope Suggests Contraception Use May Be 'Lesser Evil' For Those Fearing Zika 18FEB16

Flag of the Vatican City.svg
I'M not Catholic, but I generally like Pope Francis. He seems to be a genuine Pope for the Church, for the people, living a Christian life, leading a Christian church. Then he comes out with this ancient male proclamation granting permission for women to use contraception to avoid getting pregnant during the Zika virus crisis in Latin America and the Caribbean. He condemns abortion in response to Zika as "a crime, an absolute evil." There would be nothing wrong with this great proclamation if he had also announced the Vatican would be establishing facilities throughout the nations dealing with the Zika virus, providing compassionate Christian care for the children and families damaged by Zika for as long as they need it. 
Pope Francis speaks to journalists Thursday aboard a flight from Mexico to Italy.
Pope Francis speaks to journalists Thursday aboard a flight from Mexico to Italy.
Alessandro Di Meo/AFP/Getty Images
In wide-ranging comments aboard the papal plane, Pope Francis suggested to reporters that it might be acceptable for those fearing the Zika virus to use contraception.
The pope did not explicitly approve the use of contraception as he spoke during the flight from Mexico to Rome. But he drew a distinction between the use of abortion to respond to the threat of Zika — which he categorically opposed — and the hypothetical use of contraception.
There are concerns that the Zika virus, currently raging across Latin America, may be linked to cases of microcephaly, a severe birth defect.
A reporter on the plane had asked the pope how he felt about advice from some authorities that women at risk of Zika have abortions, and whether contraception would be the lesser of two evils, The Associated Press reports.
"Abortion is not a lesser evil. It is a crime. It is killing one person to save another. It is what the Mafia does," Francis said, according to an AP translation. "It is a crime. It is an absolute evil."
But contraception is different, the pope said, noting that "avoiding pregnancy is not an absolute evil," the AP writes.
The Vatican press office described the pope's remarks on contraception: "Using contraceptives to avoid pregnancy can be acceptable in difficult situations, he said, noting that Pope Paul VI authorized nuns in Africa to do the same half a century ago when they were threatened with rape."
That exceptional dispensation from Paul VI was not publicized at the time, the AP writes, and little is known about it.

03 September 2013

Tell Ken Cuccinelli: We're Not Fooled 3SEP13

ken cuccinelli, the repiglican tea-bagger candidate for governor has mounted a dishonest, deceptive and manipulative campaign in an attempt to make the women believe he is not a threat to their very personal decisions on birth control and types of contraception. Nothing could be farther from the truth. He is a threat to women. His life long political philosophy has been to impose "christian" sharia on society in general, and especially on women. Best for cucccinelli would be for the status of women to revert to the early 1800's, with no rights, no protections, no ability to make any decisions for themselves. So here is a chance for all women and men to tell cuccinelli what you think of him and his policies, Just click the link., and share with women and men all across Virginia. And you might be interested in my earlier post about cuccinelli at 

VA Gov. Candidate Cuccinelli Asks Supreme Court to Revive Ban on Oral, Anal Sex 27JUN13 & SNL Colonel Angus comes Home Skit (Full Video) - Saturday Night Live 2003 http://bucknacktssordidtawdryblog.blogspot.com/2013/06/va-gov-candidate-cuccinelli-asks.html

 
Planned Parenthood Advocates of Virginia

Recently, Ken Cuccinelli claimed he doesn't “think government should be doing anything about birth control or birth control devices,” and that he has “never supported legislation that invades people’s choices about contraception.” 
Really? But what about supporting “personhood” legislation that if enacted, could interfere with personal, private, medical decisions relating to birth control? In reality, Ken Cuccinelli has spent his entire career trying to prevent Virginia women from accessing birth control and other preventive care.
Join us in telling Ken Cuccinelli we aren’t fooled by his false statements on birth control.
Ken Cuccinelli has finally figured out that voters oppose his out-of-touch agenda that would limit women’s right to access birth control. And now that Ken’s positions are proving to be too extreme for voters, he’s resorting to misleading them about his own record.
But we’re not going to let him get away with it. Let’s tell Ken Cuccinelli: we know your record on women’s health and you’re going to have to run on it.
Thanks for your continued support in helping us keep Ken out this November.
Cianti Stewart-ReidExecutive DirectorPlanned Parenthood Virginia PAC
Paid for by Planned Parenthood Virginia PAC. Authorized by Terry McAuliffe, Candidate for Governor.

30 August 2012

Tennessee Republican denies claiming rape can’t cause pregnancy 28AUG12

THE fact that these men can be so callous and ignorant about rape speaks volumes about their ignorance about women, their bodies, and the physical and psychological damage rape inflicts on victims. To even suggest that a woman's body reacts to being raped in a way that doesn't allow her to become pregnant is so outrageous it defies understanding. What kind of person thinks this is possible? How do they develop that kind of twisted logic? It can only be because they have a deep seated loathing of women, and attitude that suggest they see women as less than human, beneath men in human development, less intelligent. The people who hold these views, and their supporters, are not only despicable, they are twisted and disgusting and a disgrace. God help the women in these mens lives if they are ever raped and become pregnant as a result, no doubt they will experience a more intense hell than the violence of rape itself brings.

 
Tennessee Republican Joe Carr screenshot
 
Tennessee state Rep. Joe Carr (R) has denied claiming in Tampa on Tuesday that women could not become pregnant in cases of violent rape.
According to the Memphis Flyer, Carr said that rape halted the normal biological processes that occur during conception.
Carr’s comment came during a speech by GOP strategist Frank Luntz. Luntz had asked the crowd of delegates whether Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) should drop his bid for Senate after claiming women couldn’t become pregnant from a “legitimate rape.” Carr reportedly said that Akin shouldn’t step aside and that his views were accurate.
“Rep. Joe Carr has shown today what many of the women in the General Assembly have known for a long time — he is completely and totally unfit for office,” House Minority Whip Rep. Sherry Jones said after the news of Carr’s statement broke. “Claiming that women’s bodies possess the ability to ‘close themselves off’ from pregnancy in cases of violent rape is not only biologically inaccurate, it is offensive to each and every Tennessee woman who has ever been the victim of rape.”
But Carr denies ever saying that he agreed with Akin’s views on rape and pregnancy. Carr claimed he only said Akin should not drop his bid for Senate.
Akin’s outrageous comment created a national uproar and many prominent Republicans called on Akin to abandon his bid for Senate in Missouri, but he refused to drop out of the race against incumbent Democrat Claire McCaskill.
Democrats have attempted to link other Republicans, including Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) and Mitt Romney, to Akin.
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/08/28/tennessee-republican-denies-claiming-rape-cant-cause-pregnancy/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+TheRawStory+%28The+Raw+Story%29

03 August 2012

Tea Party Senator Breaks With Top Romney Legal Adviser, Endorses Constitutional Right To Contraception 3AUG12

I seldom agree with sen rand paul r KY, but he is right on this issue and I am glad he is speaking out. From Think Progress....

Although GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney has dodged questions about whether he believes the Constitution protects a woman’s right to use birth control, one of Romney’s top legal advisers is a leading opponent of the right to contraception. Robert Bork, the former federal judge who serves as co-chair of Romney’s Justice Advisory Committee, described the first Supreme Court case to protect access to contraception as “utterly specious” and a “time bomb.”
In a surprising departure from conservative orthodoxy, Tea Party Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) broke with Romney’s legal adviser yesterday, stating that the Constitution does indeed protect a right to birth control:
“I think some conservatives get this thing wrong. They say, ‘Oh you don’t have a right to privacy because it’s not in the Constitution.’ Well, there’s not a right to private property in the Constitution either,” the libertarian-leaning senator said. . . . “I would say there is a right to privacy. It precedes the Constitution, it pre-exists, it comes, if you believe in God, from your Creator. It comes in a natural way. It’s yours,” Paul said in a speech on Internet freedom at the conservative Heritage Foundation.
Paul said he agrees with the landmark Supreme Court case Griswold v. Connecticut, which first declared that the Constitution protects privacy and invalidated a state law banning access to contraceptives.
Paul’s statement contains a number of errors — the Fifth Amendment does explicitly protect certain private property rights, for example — but it is also a clear break from the views of many conservative legal thinkers, including one of Romney’s top advisers.
http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2012/08/03/637041/tea-party-senator-breaks-with-top-romney-legal-adviser-endorses-constitutional-right-to-contraception/

16 February 2012

Obama Didn't Cave on Birth Control 10FEB12

NICK BAUMAN of Mother Jones explains how women still won this battle, thanks to Pres Obama.....
So did Barack Obama fold?
On Friday, after taking heavy criticism from Catholic groups and the political right over a regulation that would have required religiously-affiliated hospitals and universities (not churches) to offer their employees health insurance that covers birth control (with no copays), President Barack Obama went on live television to announce a shift. Now, insurance companies will have to offer employees of religious organizations the birth control coverage directly, without charging extra for it. (The details of the new birth control coverage plan are here.)
Some media outlets will no doubt call this a surrender by the president. But it's not. Here's why:
  • Everyone who was going to get birth control coverage before will still have access to it. Employees of Catholic schools and hospitals aren't always Catholic, and most sexually active women who aren't trying to get pregnant use birth control. The new rule will not allow the religious views of the leadership of religiously-affiliated organizations to dictate whether birth control is provided to their employees. The intent of the first version of the rule was to make birth control easier to get. The new rule will achieve that goal. "No woman's health should depend on who she is, where she works, or how much money she makes," Obama said in his statement. This policy ensures that.
  • The coverage will still feature no copayments. The insurance companies that are being required to offer birth control coverage directly to the employees of religious organizations will have to offer it for free. There will be no difference in cost between the plan that covers birth control and the plan that doesn't. The Obama administration justifies this by noting that studies suggest that covering birth control is cost-neutral or even saves money for health insurers because it's cheaper than pregnancy; it spaces out pregnancies, leading to healthier kids, and has other beneficial health effects.
  • The policy change still won't satisfy the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, which opposed the birth control provision from the start. It's not a cave if your opponents aren't getting what they actually want. What the bishops desire is for the entire birth control rule to be repealed. They believe that no employer—religious affiliation or not—should be required to offer birth control coverage. UPDATE, Friday 3:45 EST: The bishops have released a statement on the policy change that says they're "studying" it and it's a "first step in the right direction." It's unclear whether they'll ultimately retreat from their original position or simply say this attempt is a good step but not sufficient. 
  • The most important reproductive rights groups—Planned Parenthood, NARAL Pro-Choice America, the American Civil Liberties Union, and so on—all support the policy shift. You can bet that these politically savvy groups would be hollering to high heaven if they thought that women had been betrayed.
  • This whole scuffle was an intriguing policy dilemma, pitting women's health advocates versus faith leaders waving the banner of religious freedom. But with this move, Obama has demonstrated that it's possible to sidestep the red-hot politics of the dispute and work out a reasonable policy outcome that's backed by reproductive rights groups and the Catholic Health Association. It's not likely, though, that the social conservatives who have bashed Obama as an implacable foe of religious freedom will give it a rest.

Nick Baumann

News Editor
Nick Baumann covers national politics and civil liberties issues for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. You can also follow him on Twitter and Facebook. Email tips and insights to nbaumann [at] motherjones [dot] com. RSS |

11 February 2012

TELL YOUR SENATORS TO VOTE AGAINST THE BLUNT AMENDMENT (IT WILL UNDO THE WHOLE BIRTH CONTROL COVERAGE POLICY) 11FEB12

I am sick of this, and that is just what the repiglicans and tea-baggers are counting on, that we will be so tired of fighting for this that we will just stop. Please click the link and send a message to your Senators and tell them to reject Sen roy blunt's amendment to the transportation bill.

Today, President Obama reaffirmed his commitment to contraceptive coverage.

But the fight continues.

The Senate could vote to overturn the birth-control coverage policy at any moment.

If we lose, insurers will get the right to deny you coverage not just for contraception but for any essential health service they deem immoral.

Tell your senators to oppose the Blunt amendment!
Today, President Obama showed us all that he is firmly committed to protecting women's health.
The Obama administration's policy will make sure women of all faiths who work at religiously affiliated hospitals, universities, and service organizations will get contraceptive coverage. It guarantees that women will not encounter any barriers from their bosses or insurance plans in getting birth control without a copay.
But anti-contraception politicians are unrelenting in their attacks. Anti-choice Sen. Roy Blunt (R-MO) is using a transportation bill – of all things – to try to undo the entire birth-control coverage policy.
In fact, the Blunt amendment is so much worse than what we could have dreamed up. If we lose, insurers and employers will get the right to deny you coverage for any essential health benefit they deem immoral.
The U.S. Senate could vote on the Blunt amendment at any time. Help us fight for birth-control coverage for women, wherever they work, by contacting your senators right now.
Anti-contraception groups and politicians have launched an all-out war against the new birth-control policy. They have tried to frame their complaints as concern about "religious discrimination."
But our opponents' true goal is to allow any boss to be able to deny his employees a health plan that covers birth control.
An official with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops told USA Today that he's outraged because the new birth-control policy will cover employees at regular businesses. He actually said: "Good Catholic business people… can't in good conscience cooperate with this... If I quit this job and opened a Taco Bell, I'd be covered by the mandate."
Go ahead, pick your jaw up off the floor. Now that our opponents have showed their cards, we must make sure the Senate understands what's really at stake. Send a message to your senators right now.
If this amendment passes, it would be a disaster for women and men's health on many fronts.
It would completely undo the no-cost birth control policy, which will ensure that virtually all women get their prescription birth control covered with no copay.
The amendment would also go so far as to allow insurers to deny coverage for any essential health service they deem immoral. Think about the implications. Women and men would be at the whim of their boss for HIV treatment. Single women who wish to have a child might be refused coverage for prenatal care.
I know we can win this if we all speak out. Pro-choice Americans prove time and again – like you just did protecting funding for breast-cancer screening at Planned Parenthood – that we won't let politicians play games with our freedom and privacy. You made that victory possible. We must continue to work together and defeat this next attempt to take away women's birth-control coverage.
Thank you so much for contacting your senators.

Nancy Keenan
President, NARAL Pro-Choice America


10 February 2012

Rick Santorum: Contraception Shouldn't Be Covered By Insurance At All & Obama's Contraception Rule A Matter Of Life-Altering Care For Some 10FEB11

ONE would be able to admire rick santorum for his claim to being pro-life on the campaign trail IF he actually lived up to his claim. His latest comments on birth control is another example of his hypocrisy as well as his voluntary ignorance concerning women's issues. He is one of the gop / tea-bagger extremist intent on encouraging fear, manipulating ignorance, and encouraging prejudice and racism for political gain. His "christian sharia" political platform, if he were elected, would result not in the theocracy he desires but would bring intensified political strife and class warfare as well as destructive racial tensions and conflict. He is dangerous, a real threat to the poor, the working class and the middle class, to women and anyone who isn't white. While it is doubtful he will achieve the nomination, the poison he has spread through his political / culture war will affect the gop / tea-bagger convention and the campaign platform they adopt. If you aren't scared yet, you will be. From HuffPost....
Former Sen. Rick Santorum said on Friday afternoon that he was not persuaded by the Obama administration's revisions of rules requiring religious institutions to cover contraception as part of their workers' health care plans.
Speaking less than two hours after the president said he would give those institutions a way to exempt themselves from the policy, allowing them to punt the coverage straight to the insurance company, The Huffington Post asked Santorum whether he was placated.
"No," he replied, "not at all."
Santorum, of course, isn't the type of person that the president is likely to persuade on topics of contraception coverage. The former Pennsylvania senator is a renowned culture warrior, who has risen back to the top of the Republican primary polls by appealing to social issues. Elaborating on why he opposed the revised version of the Obama contraception rule, he explained that he didn't believe insurance companies should cover contraception at all.
"This has nothing to do with access," he said. "This is having someone pay for it, pay for something that shouldn't even be in an insurance plan anyway because it is not, really an insurable item. This is something that is affordable, available. You don't need insurance for these types of relatively small expenditures. This is simply someone trying to impose their values on somebody else, with the arm of the government doing so. That should offend everybody, people of faith and no faith that the government could get on a roll that is that aggressive."
Birth control can be readily available, sometimes on the cheap, for many women. But for a good portion of them, it's neither. Moreover, roughly 14 percent of all birth control prescriptions are written for reasons other than contraception, including ovarian cancer, ovarian cysts, endometriosis, and endometrial cancer. The Huffington Post profiled one illustrative case of the benefits of insurance-covered birth control earlier on Friday.

Obama's Contraception Rule A Matter Of Life-Altering Care For Some

Obama Contraception
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/10/obama-contraception-rule_n_1267672.html?view=print&comm_ref=false
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The debate over President Barack Obama's new contraception-coverage rule has been largely been considered through the frame of religious liberties, federal authorities and electoral consequences.
For Kimberly Dudley, however, there is a significant, often delicate, medical component being lost in the discussion.
Dudley is one of approximately five million women who suffer from Polycystic Ovary Syndrome or PCOS, a complex disorder that is a major cause of female subfertility. The condition affected her mother and her six aunts, all of whom were forced to have hysterectomies before the age of 35.
Dudley, now 35 herself, is threatened with a similar outcome. A hormonal imbalance makes it difficult if not impossible for her body to have normal menstrual cycles. Periods can last weeks if not months. Her most recent one started on October 3, 2011. It ended three weeks ago.
"It almost killed me," she said, "the doctors couldn't stop the bleeding." They tried a number of medications before finding one that worked: a double-dosage of Aygestin, a drug that can be classified as a birth control.
"Had the last one not worked I would have likely had a hysterectomy," she said.
The Obama administration's rule change would force hospitals and schools owned and run by the Catholic Church and other religious organizations to offer health care plans to their employees that cover drugs like Aygestin. There is a year grace period before it becomes law and reports early Friday morning suggest that the administration will alter the language to allow religious groups more leeway in (and distance from) providing such coverage. Even when the new rule takes effect, Dudley won't be directly affected. A self-employed real estate broker, she pays $55 every month for her medication. Her insurance company covers the rest.
But that doesn't mean she doesn't have a deeply personal stake in the game. Her husband is a dean at a local North Carolina college. Were he to get a job offer at a Catholic university in one of the states that don't require those institutions to cover the co-pays of their employee's contraception, with her then being dependent on his plan, they'd be unlikely to move. "It would be sad he would have to make job choices based on something like this," she said.
Dudley brings to the debate a perspective that has been largely absent from public view. When the White House initially weighed the merits of changing federal policy on contraceptives, a cadre of largely female advisers invested in expanding health care coverage for women were pitted against mainly male aides, including several prominent Catholics, who warned that it would cause a political firestorm. Since the former won out, the president has come under intense pressure to reverse course.
Members of the Catholic Church, reportedly prepping for months for the battle, have been vocal with their concerns that the rule forces them to violate tenets of faith. Republicans and even some Democrats have warned that the policy represents a dangerous overreach by the federal government. It has been less common to hear from those whose lives (and not just their sex lives) are directly affected by current law.
"I'm a married woman," Dudley said. "I am a Christian. I don't believe in abortion. But this has nothing to do with any of that. This is a health issue for me and for millions of women."


Kimberly Dudley

The Guttmacher Institute estimates that roughly 14 percent of birth control prescriptions are written for non-contraceptive purposes, helping some 1.5 million women with issues like ovarian cancer, ovarian cysts, endometriosis, and endometrial cancer. Their stories, filled with difficult details of medical trauma and personal sacrifice, aren't usually the fodder for piqued political conversation, at least not until this week.
Dudley, for her part, kept the details of her condition secret from all but close friends and family. She only came forward on Thursday morning, when she sent an email to a wider group after finally hitting a boiling point with news coverage of the controversy. She forwarded that email to The Huffington Post shortly after.
Her first inclination that something might be wrong came when she was 18 years old. She went to the campus nurse at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, who recommended that she see an off-campus doctor. An ultrasound was conducted confirming PCOS. Her life since has been filled with efforts to manage the consequences. She shyly changes topic when people ask why she doesn't have more children (she and her husband have a nine year old.) She misses big events and birthday parties, including her best friend's 40th.
"When you are bleeding that high a volume there are times where you have to wear adult diapers," she says, by way of explaining why she's occasionally housebound.
Even more serious has been the medical complications. One recent large loss of blood resulted in severe iron deficiency and anemia. Things stabilized eventually. But Dudley said her doctor later told her that the doctor had thought she was going to die.
Finding the right medication has changed her life, she says. And she counts herself among the fortunate for having the resources to cover the costs. But she also recognizes how close she comes to being among the cast of the less lucky.
The Church may be sincere in arguing that Obama's new rule violates their consciousness. Lawmakers may be earnest in expressing concerns about the reach of government into world of contraception policy. But that doesn't change the fact that many women suffering from Dudley's condition, as she notes, "do not have access to health insurance coverage to pay for this medication simply because they work at places owned or run by the Catholic Church."

Why I'm Feeling So Hard-Nosed Over the Contraception Affair 10FEB12 &Most of Obama's "Controversial" Birth Control Rule Was Law During Bush Years 8FEB12

WELL said Kevin Drum, my sentiments on this exactly.....And check out the history of this rule, it has been in existence since 2000! From MOJO.....
dudes arguing
Over the past week I've written a few posts expressing support for the Obama administration's decision to require health care plans to cover contraception, as well as for its decision to permit only a very narrow exemption for religious organizations. I haven't really laid out the whole case, though, and today I want to do that in telegraphic form. Then I want to tell you the real reason that my reaction to this has been stronger than you might have guessed it would be, especially considering that this isn't a subject I wade into frequently. But that won't come until the end of the post. First, the bullet point warm-up:
  • In any case like this, you have to look at two separate issues: (1) How important is the secular public purpose of the policy? And (2) how deeply held is the religious objection to it?
  • On the first issue, I'd say that the public purpose here is pretty strong. Health care in general is very clearly a matter of broad public concern; treating women's health care on a level playing field with men's is, today, a deep and widely-accepted principle; and contraception is quite clearly critical to women's health. Making it widely and easily available is a legitimate issue of public policy.
  • On the second issue, I simply don't believe that the religious objection here is nearly as strong as critics are making it out to be. As I've mentioned before, even the vast majority of Catholics don't believe that contraception is immoral. Only the formal church hierarchy does. What's more, as my colleague Nick Baumann points out, federal regulations have required religious hospitals and universities to offer health care plans that cover contraception for over a decade. (The fact that some such employers don't cover birth control is mostly the result of lax enforcement.) It's true that the Obama regulation tightens this requirement, but only modestly: it covers organizations with fewer than 15 employees and it bans copays. Dozens of states already have similar rules on the books. So when Kirsten Powers says, "One thing we can be sure of: the Catholic Church will shut down before it violates its faith," that's just wrong. They've been working under similar rules for a long time without turning it into Armageddon.
  • Some matters of conscience are worth respecting and some aren't. If, say, Catholic doctrine forbade white doctors from treating black patients, nobody would be defending them. The principle of racial nondiscrimination is simply too important to American culture and we'd insist that the church respect this. I think the same is true today of the principle of nondiscrimination against women, as well as the principle that women should have control of their own reproduction. Like racial discrimination laws, churches that operate major institutions in the public square have to respect this whether they like it or not.
  • This new policy doesn't apply to churches themselves or their devotional arms. It applies only to nominally religious enterprises like hospitals and universities that serve secular purposes, take taxpayer dollars, employ thousands of non-Catholic women, and are already required to obey a wide variety of secular regulations. At organizations like these, the money that pays for employee health care doesn't come from the church, it comes out of the income stream they get from their customers and clients.
  • What's more, this is hardly a unique matter of conscience. Anyone who pays taxes, including Catholic bishops, ends up financially supporting things they disapprove of. Public regulations often involve financial commitments too, and this one is no different. It's also pretty minuscule. This is an issue that's very clearly being blown up for partisan political reasons far beyond its actual impact on religious organizations or religious conscience.
Now, having said all that, it's also true that I'm normally fairly sympathetic to granting religious exemptions to public policy. You can make a case—not a great one, but a case—that allowing an exemption to the new contraceptive policy wouldn't actually work a huge hardship on the women affected. And the Catholic Church's objection to contraception, wrongheaded though I think it is, is plainly of long standing. This is no made-up issue.
So why am I really feeling so hard-nosed about this? The answer goes back a few years, to the controversy over pharmacists who refused to fill prescriptions for the morning-after pill. I was appalled: If you're a pharmacist, then you fill people's prescriptions. That's the job, full stop. If you object to filling prescriptions, then you need to find another occupation.
But of course, the entire right-wing outrage machine went into high gear over this. And it was at that point that my position shifted: if this was the direction things were going, then it was obvious that there would be no end to religious exemption arguments. The whole affair was, I thought, way over the top, and yet it got the the full-throated support of virtually every conservative pundit and talking head anyway. This was, in plain terms, simply a war on contraception.
So I changed my mind. Instead of believing as a default that we should take religious exemptions seriously and put the burden of proof on the rest of us to explain why they shouldn't be allowed, I now believe that neutral public policy comes first and the burden of proof is now up to churches to provide convincing arguments that (a) An important matter of conscience is being violated, and (b) The public policy in question isn't important enough to be applied across the board. On the matter of contraception, I don't think they've made a convincing case for either one.

Kevin Drum

Political Blogger
Kevin Drum is a political blogger for Mother Jones. For more of his stories, click here. RSS |

Most of Obama's "Controversial" Birth Control Rule Was Law During Bush Years

The right has freaked out over an Obama administration rule requiring employers to offer birth control to their employees. Most companies already had to do that.

| Wed Feb. 8, 2012 2:10 PM PST

obama facepalm
President Barack Obama's decision to require most employers to cover birth control and insurers to offer it at no cost has created a firestorm of controversy. But the central mandate—that most employers have to cover preventative care for women—has been law for over a decade. This point has been completely lost in the current controversy, as Republican presidential candidates and social conservatives claim that Obama has launched a war on religious liberty and the Catholic Church.
Despite the longstanding precedent, "no one screamed" until now, said Sara Rosenbaum, a health law expert at George Washington University.
In December 2000, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission ruled that companies that provided prescription drugs to their employees but didn't provide birth control were in violation of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which prevents discrimination on the basis of sex. That opinion, which the George W. Bush administration did nothing to alter or withdraw when it took office the next month, is still in effect today—and because it relies on Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, it applies to all employers with 15 or more employees. Employers that don't offer prescription coverage or don't offer insurance at all are exempt, because they treat men and women equally—but under the EEOC's interpretation of the law, you can't offer other preventative care coverage without offering birth control coverage, too.
"It was, we thought at the time, a fairly straightforward application of Title VII principles," a top former EEOC official who was involved in the decision told Mother Jones. "All of these plans covered Viagra immediately, without thinking, and they were still declining to cover prescription contraceptives. It's a little bit jaw-dropping to see what is going on now…There was some press at the time but we issued guidances that were far, far more controversial."
After the EEOC opinion was approved in 2000, reproductive rights groups and employees who wanted birth control access sued employers that refused to comply. The next year, in Erickson v. Bartell Drug Co., a federal court agreed with the EEOC's reasoning. Reproductive rights groups and others used that decision as leverage to force other companies to settle lawsuits and agree to change their insurance plans to include birth control. Some subsequent court decisions echoed Erickson, and some went the other way, but the rule (absent a Supreme Court decision) remained, and over the following decade, the percentage of employer-based plans offering contraceptive coverage tripled to 90 percent.
"We have used [the EEOC ruling] many times in negotiating with various employers," says Judy Waxman, the vice president for health and reproductive rights at the National Women's Law Center. "It has been in active use all this time. [President Obama's] policy is only new in the sense that it covers employers with less than 15 employees and with no copay for the individual. The basic rule has been in place since 2000."
Not even religious employers were exempt from the impact of the EEOC decision. Although Title VII allows religious institutions to discriminate on religious grounds, it doesn't allow them to discriminate on the basis of sex—the kind of discrimination at issue in the EEOC ruling. DePaul University, the largest Roman Catholic university in America, added birth control coverage to its plans after receiving an EEOC complaint several years ago. (DePaul officials did not respond to a request for comment.)
As recently as last year, the EEOC was moderating a dispute between the administrators of Belmont Abbey, a Catholic institution in North Carolina, and several of its employees who had their birth control coverage withdrawn after administrators realized it was being offered. The Weekly Standard opined on the issue in 2009—more proof that religious employers were being asked to cover contraception far before the Obama administration issued its new rule on January 20 of this year.
"The current freakout," Judy Waxman says, is largely occurring because the EEOC policy "isn't as widely known…and it hasn't been uniformly enforced." But it's still unclear whether Obama's Health and Human Services department will enforce the new rule any more harshly than the old one. The administration has already given organizations a year-long grace period to comply. Asked to explain how the agency would make employers do what it wanted, an HHS official told Mother Jones that it would "enforce this the same way we enforce everything else in the law."

Nick Baumann

News Editor
Nick Baumann covers national politics and civil liberties issues for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. You can also follow him on Twitter and Facebook. Email tips and insights to nbaumann [at] motherjones [dot] com. RSS |

09 February 2012

Barack Obama's Contraception Ruling Backed By Previously Unreleased Survey 9FEB12

REDEFINING RAPE, CALLOUSNES
­S ABOUT INCEST, INDIFFEREN­CE ABOUT THE HEALTH OF PREGNANT WOMEN, RESTRICTIO­NS ON ACCESS TO BIRTH CONTROL, all characteri­stics of the gop / tea-bagger­, Catholic bishops and evangelica­l right-wing extremist war against women. For the most part this war is being waged by men; men in congress, male presidenti­al wannabes, the male leadership of the Catholic church, the male leadership of extreme right wing evangelica­ls. Men who have no problem with VIAGRA being covered by health insurance plans. Men who want to keep women in their place; servile, subjugated­, obedient, basically barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen. They seek to impose a most unchristia­n "christian sharia" rule on society, especially on women. We can not allow them to succeed. Join the ACLU's campaign to support and defend Pres Obama's regulation­s on birth control (part of the Affordable Care Act) by clicking the link
https://se­cure.aclu.­org/site/A­dvocacy?cm­d=display&­page=UserA­ction&id=4­063&s_subs­rc=120208_­HHS_email
and sending a letter to your Rep and Senators in D.C. This from HuffPost......
WASHINGTON -- Hoping to hold the line on President Barack Obama's controversial contraception ruling, which requires most religiously affiliated employers to cover the costs of their employees' birth control, Democrats are passing around private polling data from last August showing that a majority of the country -- including Catholics -- actually favors the policy.
A Democratic source on Thursday morning sent over previously unreleased data put together by pollster Celinda Lake for the Herndon Alliance, a non-partisan pro-health care reform coalition. The survey, conducted with more than 1,000 people, focuses on all aspects of the Affordable Care Act.
Its release was not authorized by the Herndon Alliance. For the Democratic party, however, the poll serves an important function. It contained a series of questions that are highly relevant to the debate over whether religious-oriented institutions should be required to offer contraception as part of their health care plans.
The poll asks respondents to react to the following argument, the language of which seems fairly evenly phrased by the standards of the current debate.
"Requiring health insurers to cover contraceptives violates the rights of people who belong to religions that don't believe in artificial contraception. The Catholic Church morally opposes birth control and Orthodox Jews and some Protestants find birth control objectionable. Forcing religious groups, individuals, health providers, and health plans to perform or pay for a service that they may find morally objectionable is wrong."
According to the results, 42 percent of respondents found this argument convincing, but 52 percent were not convinced. The majority of respondents, then, didn't believe religious objections trumped employers' responsibility to cover contraceptives.
Further down in the survey are equally revealing numbers. The poll asked respondents to react to the fact that the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops "has sharply criticized the new rule requiring plans to cover contraception and birth control with no co-pays or deductible." Twenty percent said it made them view the Affordable Care Act less favorably, 18 percent said it made them view it more favorably, while a vast majority, 57 percent, said that it made no difference on their perception of the law at all. Those trend lines basically held when the respondents polled were only Catholics -- a full 53 percent said they weren't persuaded by the bishops.
Some of these results are driven by female respondents, who tend to be more supportive of contraception coverage requirements than men. But that hardly makes the data any less politically relevant. There is a perception that the administration's rule-making decision has opened it up to political disaster. The numbers don't necessarily reflect that.
Below is the full survey with the relevant data on pages 7 and 12.
contraception data
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/112557632/contraception-data 

The Republican War on Contraception from MOTHER JONES 9FEB12

REDEFINING RAPE, CALLOUSNESS ABOUT INCEST, INDIFFERENCE ABOUT THE HEALTH OF PREGNANT WOMEN, RESTRICTIONS ON ACCESS TO BIRTH CONTROL, all characteristics of the gop / tea-bagger, Catholic bishops and evangelical right-wing extremist war against women. For the most part this war is being waged by men; men in congress, male presidential wannabes, the male leadership of the Catholic church, the male leadership of extreme right wing evangelicals. Men who have no problem with VIAGRA being covered by health insurance plans. Men who want to keep women in their place; servile, subjugated, obedient, basically barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen. They seek to impose a most unchristian "christian sharia" rule on society, especially on women. We can not allow them to succeed. Join the ACLU's campaign to support and defend Pres Obama's regulations on birth control (part of the Affordable Care Act) by clicking the link
https://secure.aclu.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=4063&s_subsrc=120208_HHS_email 
and sending a letter to your Rep and Senators in D.C. This from Mother Jones......

The Republican War on Contraception

Not satisfied with restricting abortion rights, the GOP is now coming after your birth control.

discared birth control
Last year was not a great one for abortion rights. First, congressional Republicans attempted to deny statutory rape victims access to Medicaid-funded abortions (twice). Then GOP-dominated state legislatures pushed record numbers of laws limiting abortion rights, including proposals that could have treated killing abortion providers as "justifiable homicide."
Yet in the past six months, social conservatives have widened their offensive, and their new target is clear: Not satisfied with making it harder to obtain legal abortions, they want to limit access to birth control, too.
"Contraception is under attack in a way it really wasn't in the past few years," says Judy Waxman, the vice president for health and reproductive rights at the National Women's Law Center. "In 2004, we could not find any group—the National Right to Life Committee, the Bush campaign, anyone—that would go on the record to say they're opposed to birth control," adds Elizabeth Shipp, the political director for NARAL Pro-Choice America. "We couldn't find them in 2006 either, and in 2008 it was just fringe groups. In 2010, 2011, and this year, it's just exploded."
The first sign of the new assault came last October, when Mississippi activists and congressional Republicans pushed legislation on the state and federal level, respectively, that would have treated zygotes—a.k.a. fertilized human eggs—as legal "persons." If the definition of legal personhood is changed so that it begins when sperm meets an egg, hormonal birth control or barrier devices that prevent zygotes from implanting in the uterine wall could become illegal, making using an IUD tantamount to murder. Yet some 40 percent of House Republicans and a quarter of their allies in the Senate back bills that would do just that.
That's not all. Earlier this year, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), a rising conservative star who's considered a possible pick for the 2012 GOP vice-presidential nomination, introduced a bill that could cut off birth control access for millions of women by allowing even non-religious employers to refuse birth control coverage as long as they cite a religious reason. In other words, if your boss doesn't want to cover birth control in the company health plan because he says it would offend his religious beliefs, he wouldn't have to—even if his Cialis was still covered. Rubio's bill could also allow states to refuse to provide birth control through Medicaid, which provides family planning services to millions of poor women.
“These are people who have never, ever approved of birth control, and they saw an opportunity to take it one step further.”
The Republican presidential candidates also have come out against birth control. Mitt Romney has slammed President Barack Obama for requiring most employers to offer insurance that provides birth control at no cost to women who want it, even though Romney himself maintained a similar rule as governor of Massachusetts.
Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum, who won the non-binding Missouri primary as well as the Minnesota and Colorado caucuses on Tuesday, has also slammed Obama's decision. But he's also gone farther than that, suggesting that any form of birth control is immoral. "Many of the Christian faith have said, well, that's okay, contraception is okay," Santorum, a devout Catholic, said in October. "It's not okay. It's a license to do things in a sexual realm that is counter to how things are supposed to be." As Salon's Irin Carmon has documented, Santorum thinks Griswold v. Connecticut, the Supreme Court decision that said states can not deny married couples access to contraception, should be overturned.
Even previously uncontroversial ideas about contraception are now being questioned. As I explained in this story about Obama's birth-control policy, most of the administration's recently-issued rule requiring companies to provide birth control to their employees has been widely accepted federal law for a decade. Requiring employers to provide birth control if they provide other preventative services was so uncontroversial that most employers—even Catholic universities like DePaul, in Chicago—simply changed their policies and offered birth control to avoid being sued. The percentage of employers offering birth control coverage tripled in a decade. The national controversy only erupted after Obama issued the new rule in January.
NARAL's Shipp thinks the battlefield has definitely shifted. "First, everyone thought it was all about abortion access and abortion rights," she says. "But they decided to move the goalposts, and it's been kind of stunning how far to the right they've gone. These are people who have never, ever approved of birth control, and they saw an opportunity to take it one step further."
The White House probably isn't entirely unhappy with all the fighting over contraception. As the Washington Post's Sarah Kliff wrote, the birth control issue gives Obama's reelection campaign "a chance to widen the reproductive health debate beyond abortion" and energize young, secular abortion-rights supporters who might not otherwise vote.
Republicans who support abortion rights have warned their fellow GOPers that picking a fight over contraception could be a disaster. But even that hasn't slowed down the onslaught—on Wednesday, Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-Ohio), warned that he would soon push forward legislation that would allow employers to refuse to provide birth control to their employees. Boehner's Senate counterpart, Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), noted that several Republican senators have already introduced bills on the subject. One of those bills is Rubio's aforementioned Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
"I'm a little bit stunned with how far they have gone on birth control with absolutely no regard for the political consequences," Shipp continues. "Whether it's Rick Santorum, Mitt Romney—I don't think Newt Gingrich—if any of these guys think they're going to be able to come back to the middle after the attacks they've made on birth control, they're sadly mistaken, because the general public thinks they're just whack-a-doodle."

Nick Baumann

News Editor
Nick Baumann covers national politics and civil liberties issues for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. You can also follow him on Twitter and Facebook. Email tips and insights to nbaumann [at] motherjones [dot] com. RSS |

08 February 2012

Religious freedom or discrimination? & More Catholics support contraception coverage than other Americans 7FEB12 & Contraception Mandate, Five Reasons Why Obama Is Losing The Fight 8FEB12

THIS "religious war" being waged for the hearts and minds of the American electorate is a fabrication of the Catholic church and right wing religious extremist, using deception, manipulation and propaganda, methods Christ himself never had to use. The Obama administration is right in their decision to require religious affiliated public institutions to include birth control in the health insurance policies made available to their employees and they are also right in NOT requiring churches, synagogs, and mosques, to provide birth control to their employees if doing so violates the tenants of their faith. When one considers 98% of Catholics use birth control and 58% of Catholics, 68% of religiously unaffiliated Americans, 55% of all Americans, 62% of all women, 71% of Democrats and 51% of Independents all believe employer health plans should be required to provide free birth control coverage, it becomes obvious this "war" is nothing more than a propaganda campaign being waged by the male leadership of these religious groups for political gain, the subjugation of women and not religious rights and religious freedom. You can support the Obama administration and women's access to birth control by participating in the ACLU's campaign to pressure Congress and HHS not to revoke these new regulations here https://secure.aclu.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=4063&s_subsrc=120208_HHS_email 
Check out more on this action below, and the articles from Raw Story and Huffpost......
Because Freedom Can't Protect Itself 


Anti-choice forces around the country are yelling from the rooftops about religious freedom. But what they actually mean is the use of religion to discriminate and deny millions of women access to birth control.

Now anti-family planning politicians in Congress are getting in on the action and trying to reverse the President's critical decision, which would ensure access to birth control for millions of women.

We must stand with President Obama — believe me, he's hearing from the other side, starting with Speaker Boehner who has pledged to reverse this rule.

Tell your members of Congress: Stand up to right-wing efforts to use religion to discriminate and deny millions of women urgently needed access to birth control. 

Let's be clear. The current law does not require religious institutions like churches or synagogues to include birth control in their employee's health insurance.

But, when lobbying groups — led by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops — insisted that the exemption be expanded to include religiously affiliated hospitals, universities and other institutions, jeopardizing coverage for millions of women, the Obama administration drew a line in the sand.

If the lobbying groups get their way, a woman teaching at a Catholic university could not get coverage. Or, a nurse working at an evangelical Christian hospital could be denied access to basic health care.

Tell Congress to stand with the President and American women.

Anti-choice forces are screaming that the Obama administration's efforts to protect women's access to birth control are part of a "war on religion." This explosive accusation is untrue but their hope is that if they repeat it often enough, they can get Congress to roll back our rights. We can't let that happen.

Religious freedom is about protecting people of all faiths, not imposing the values of some on the rest of us.

Thank you for acting quickly in this critical moment,


Laura W. Murphy
Director, Washington Legislative Office



© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10004


More Catholics support contraception coverage than other Americans


U.S. Catholics support birth control/contraception (Shutterstock)
 http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/02/07/more-catholics-support-contraception-coverage-than-other-americans/
Catholics in the U.S. are more likely that other Americans say that employers should be required to provide insurance that covers free contraception, according to a recent poll.
A survey released by the Public Religion Research Institute on Tuesday found that 58 percent of Catholics think businesses should be required to provide health plans with free birth control, compared with 55 percent of all Americans who agreed with the requirement. At 38 percent, white evangelical protestants were the least likely to agree free contraception should be provided by employers.
Religiously unaffiliated Americans, at 68 percent, were the most likely say that company health plans should cover birth control for free.
Among political parties, 73 percent of Democrats and 51 percent of independents said health insurance should include free birth control. But only 36 percent of Republicans agreed with that point of view.
The poll also uncovered a significant gender gap. Overall, 62 percent of women said contraception should be provided at no cost, while only 47 percent of men thought it should be a requirement.
In recent weeks, a controversy has erupted over the issue of employers being required to provide birth control coverage, with Catholic leaders and many conservative politicians taking the view that it should be optional.
The Obama administration announced last month it would stand by a policy that requires virtually all private insurance policies to cover family planning, including female contraceptives, essentially guaranteeing near universal access to birth control once all the provisions of the Affordable Care Act are implemented.
Last week, thousands of Catholic parishioners were read letters by Catholic Bishops in the U.S. that condemned the Obama administration for that decision.
“We cannot — we will not — comply with this unjust law,” Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted wrote in just one of the numerous letters. “People of faith cannot be made second class citizens. We are already joined by our brothers and sisters of all faiths and many others of good will in this important effort to regain our religious freedom. Our parents and grandparents did not come to these shores to help build America’s cities and towns, its infrastructure and institutions, its enterprise and culture, only to have their posterity stripped of their God given rights.”
David Axelrod, a top adviser to President Barack Obama’s re-election campaign, suggested on Tuesday that the administration was open to working with Catholic hospitals and universities over their objections to providing birth control services to women.

Contraception Mandate, Five Reasons Why Obama Is Losing The Fight
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/08/obama-contraception-losing-fight_n_1263919.html 
By David Gibson
Religion News Service

(RNS) The White House has surprised observers and disappointed some liberal allies by signaling that it is willing to compromise and provide a broader religious exemption in its controversial regulations requiring all employers to provide free contraception coverage.
Given that birth control use is almost universal -- even among Catholics -- many wonder why the Obama administration could wind up retreating on its pledge.
Here are five reasons that may help explain the political dynamic the president is facing:
1. It's about religious freedom, not birth control
U.S. Catholic bishops, who led the battle against the Health and Human Services Department mandate, know that they long ago lost their own flock on the contraception issue -- 98 percent of Catholics use birth control, according to surveys.
So they have carefully reframed the issue as a fight for religious freedom -- an effort to keep the government from forcing the Catholic Church and other religious groups to subsidize something that goes against their teachings. That makes it a violation of conscience, a sacred principle that transcends any specific tenet of faith.
That argument also lends itself to the kind of heated rhetoric that plays well in today's supercharged political atmosphere. For example, bishops and their allies are accusing the president of "anti-Catholicism" and worse: "The Obama administration has just told the Catholics of the United States, 'To hell with you!'" Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik said after the HHS regulations were announced.
The bishops don't have as much credibility with the laity as they used to, thanks to the clergy sex abuse scandal, among other things. But Catholics are still a potent tribe, and if outsiders are seen as attacking the church, Catholics can get defensive -- and they can get even.
2. Obama has lost even the support of his liberal Catholic allies
Case in point: the HHS mandate has been opposed by liberal and centrist Catholics who have supported the administration on a range of other issues -- including the Catholic Health Association and the NETWORK social justice lobby -- and even went to bat to help pass health care reform despite threats from the bishops.
The president "utterly botched" the religious exemptions issue, wrote Washington Post columnist and liberal Catholic E.J. Dionne, and "Obama threw his progressive Catholic allies under the bus."
"J'accuse!" Michael Sean Winters, a columnist for the liberal National Catholic Reporter, wrote in a florid column that channeled Emile Zola's famous 1898 letter accusing the French government of anti-Semitism in the Dreyfus affair. "The issue of conscience protections is so foundational, I do not see how I ever could, in good conscience, vote for this man again."
3. It's not just Catholics
Even though evangelicals and other conservative Protestants generally don't have religious objections to contraception, they do have a big problem with "big government" and with perceived infringements on religious freedom.
Evangelicals -- both their leaders and their troops -- have never been big Barack Obama supporters anyway, so they were happy to provide any electoral and rhetorical muscle the Catholic hierarchy could not muster.
"We do not exaggerate when we say that this is the greatest threat to religious freedom in our lifetime," evangelical leaders Timothy George and Chuck Colson wrote in an open letter to their fellow believers on Wednesday (Feb. 8). George and Colson compared the administration mandates to policies enacted in Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler.
4. It gives Republicans a potent campaign wedge issue
Mitt Romney wasted no time in accusing Obama of launching an "assault on religion" by way of the contraception mandate, and he declared that his first act as president would be to overturn the HHS regulations. "Remarkably, under this president's administration, there is an assault on religion, an assault on the conviction and the religious beliefs of members of our society," Romney said.
Romney's rivals, Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum, were not to be outdone, and ramped up their rhetoric against Obama -- while also noting that Romney had accepted similar policies while he was governor of Massachusetts.
In short, this is a political fight that the White House neither wants nor needs in an already tough re-election campaign.
5. Obama needs the Catholic vote
In particular, he needs the support of white Catholics, which is the core of this large swing vote (nearly one-quarter of the electorate). They are concentrated in crucial battleground states like Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania, and while Obama won the overall Catholic vote 54 percent to 46 percent in 2008, he lost the white Catholic vote, 47 percent to 53 percent.
"To the extent Catholic voters think of this as a religious liberty issue, it does have the potential to pull Catholic voters toward Republicans or away from Democrats," John Green, an expert on religious voting patterns and director of the University of Akron's Ray C. Bliss Institute of Applied Politics, told Bloomberg Businessweek.
A poll on the contraception mandate released Tuesday by the Public Religion Research Institute showed Catholics overall tended to support free contraceptive coverage, but white Catholics were evenly split on the issue. The Obama campaign can't afford to sacrifice any of those votes, or risk watching the issue grow as a political liability when the election season heats up.