NORTON META TAG

Showing posts with label "war" on religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label "war" on religion. Show all posts

29 February 2012

Is Rick Santorum Missing JFK's Point On Religion? 29FEB12

THE person guilty of waging war on religion isn't Pres Obama, it is rick santorum. His Christianity is nothing like the Christianity I was baptised in, confirmed in, taught in Sunday school and is my faith today. I was taught to believe in the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, salvation through belief in and acceptance of Jesus Christ as Savior and the promise of Heaven. I was taught the compassion of Christ, that Christians and the Church living lives based on the teachings of Christ are the best examples of Christianity for the world. The Beatitudes, Mathew 25, and the parables of Jesus concerning prayer, forgiveness, self-righteousness, wealth, poverty, humility, mercy, and compassion are the the lessons I try to keep in my life in my relationships with my family, friends, coworkers, and any others I  encounter in my life. And I remember I am human, and a sinner, and fail to live up to the hopes of my God, but the mercy of God grants absolution and I keep going in my faith, doing the best I can.
I do not recognize Christianity in rick santorum's constant use of lies, deception, and manipulation in his political campaign (check out PolitiFact 
http://www.politifact.com/search/?q=santorum )and have to question what god he is really serving in his campaign for president; the god of lust for power and wealth or God the Father of the Holy Trinity. santorum rails against social moral decay in America, condemning abortion, the LGBT community, birth control, and tolerance of non-Christian faiths without being able to backup his beliefs and political platform with New Testament scripture. His social policies and most definitely his economic policies cause harm to the poor, to children and to families and favor the rich and powerful, the exact opposite of the basic teachings of Jesus Christ. If he really believes he represents Christianity in his campaign for president I can honestly understand why non-believers I know are disgusted by him. rick santorum does not represent the Christianity I believe in, and I have to believe he doesn't represent the Christianity a vast majority of Americans believe in either. This from NPR......
Then-Sen. John F. Kennedy participates in a question-and-answer session with the Ministers' Association of Greater Houston on Sept. 12, 1960, in Houston. In a speech to the group, Kennedy addressed concerns about his Catholicism and his run for the presidency.
Enlarge Houston Chronicle/AP Then-Sen. John F. Kennedy participates in a question-and-answer session with the Ministers' Association of Greater Houston on Sept. 12, 1960, in Houston. In a speech to the group, Kennedy addressed concerns about his Catholicism and his run for the presidency.

When GOP presidential candidate Rick Santorum was growing up, he says, John F. Kennedy was a hero in his Catholic home.
In a speech last year, he said he had always heard glowing reports of Kennedy's speech about religion to Protestant ministers in 1960.
"And then very late in my political career, I had the opportunity to read the speech and I almost threw up," Santorum told a group of college students last year. "You should read the speech. In my opinion, it was the beginning of the secular movement of politicians to separate their faith from the public square."

Watch Kennedy's 1960 Speech

Credit: JFK Presidential Library And Museum
In his Sept. 12, 1960, speech in Houston, then-Sen. John Kennedy said:
"I believe in an America where the separation of church and state is absolute — where no Catholic prelate would tell the president, should he be Catholic, how to act, and no Protestant minister would tell his parishoners for whom to vote — where no church or church school is granted any public funds or political preference — and where no man is denied public office merely because his religion differs from the president who might appoint him or the people who might elect him.

"I believe in an America that is officially neither Catholic, Protestant nor Jewish — where no public official either requests or accepts instructions on public policy from the pope, the National Council of Churches or any other ecclesiastical source — where no religious body seeks to impose its will directly or indirectly upon the general populace or the public acts of its officials — and where religious liberty is so indivisible that an act against one church is treated as an act against all."
Read the full transcript at the JFK Library website.
Santorum said Tuesday that he regrets his graphic language. But he insists Kennedy's view was wrong, particularly the opening, when Kennedy said, "I believe in an America where the separation of church and state is absolute, where no Catholic prelate would tell the president, should he be Catholic, how to act, and no Protestant minister would tell his parishioners for whom to vote."
On Sunday, Santorum told ABC's George Stephanopoulos that Kennedy set the foundation for expelling faith from politics. "What kind of country do we live in that says only people of nonfaith can come in the public square and make their case?" he asked rhetorically.
But Shaun Casey, who teaches politics and religion at Wesley Theological Seminary and who authored a political biography of Kennedy called The Making of a Catholic President, says he thinks that's "a radical misunderstanding of what Kennedy was trying to convey in that speech."
Casey says Kennedy would have been "booed off the stage" if he implied there was no place for religion in public life. He says Kennedy was explicit: While religious leaders should not tell politicians how to vote, they can and should instruct politicians on faith and morals.
The speech has to be read in context, Casey says. Kennedy was running in a political climate that was openly hostile to Catholics.
"And the primary issue is the accusation that Catholicism represents a church and a state, that inevitably to be Catholic means you want to have a Catholic-dominated state — and that Catholic leaders will coerce Catholic politicians to make that so," Casey says.
Fifty years later, the political climate is vastly different.
"In 1960, the issue was differences between religious affiliations — such as between Protestants and Catholics," says John Green, a political scientist at the University of Akron.
Green says many Protestants considered the pope to be a threat. Now, conservative Catholics and Protestants have joined forces — and they consider the big threat to be secularism.
"The conflict seems to be placed around the level of religiosity — with more traditionally religious people in most, if not all, religious communities having different views about politics than those who are more progressive or more liberal or less traditional," Green says.
Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum, shown at Temple Baptist Church in Powell, Tenn., on Wednesday, says John F. Kennedy set the foundation for expelling faith from politics.
Enlarge Mark Humphrey/AP Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum, shown at Temple Baptist Church in Powell, Tenn., on Wednesday, says John F. Kennedy set the foundation for expelling faith from politics.
He says Santorum is finding a receptive audience among conservative, white evangelical Protestants: He won 51 percent of them in Michigan and is favored among them in polls nationwide. Indeed, Santorum says the Obama administration is waging a war on religion, even claiming that the president practices a "phony theology."
And the president is not the only target.
"One of the reasons I think Santorum is talking about religion is also to shine a bright light on his opponent Mitt Romney's reticence to talk about religion," Casey says. "So it's not just about getting the record 'straight' on JFK and attacking Democrats. It has the added benefit of shining a bright light on the fact that Mitt Romney ... is very hesitant to address the issue."
Romney is a Mormon, and polls suggest that makes many Republican primary voters uncomfortable. Romney tried to address that issue five years ago, in a speech modeled on Kennedy's. But unlike 50 years ago, Romney's speech does not appear to have put voters' concerns to rest.

 

16 February 2012

Why I hate Religion, But Love Jesus – A Response from the SARCASTIC LUTHERAN 13JAN12


WITH all the controversy the past few weeks involving religion and politics, church and state, and the vastly divergent views on morality and faith expressed by so many of our religious and political "leaders" it is easy for anyone and everyone to become jaded about organized religion. Here is a great post from Nadia Bolz-Weber, the Sarcastic Lutheran, in response to the video "Why I hate Religion, But Love Jesus".......

This video went viral this week and I’ve been asked by the ELCA office for my response (to be posted on their website.)
Here it is: I totally get it.  I hate the way in which the church is more of a behavior modification program and a purity system than a place where we hear the truth of who God is and the truth of who we are because of who God is.
I also resent the way in which the term “Christian” has become synonomous with a conservative social agenda and exclusion of the weak the poor and the outcast (namely the people Jesus chose to hang out with)
I too reject religion that does little more than prop up an identity of sanctification and righteousness based in the successful adoption a particular affect, style, personality and way of speaking.
I too think that Jesus is about grace and being with those on the margins and the unbounded way in which God is always coming TO us.
But…
I believe that religion can be beautiful.  For every war it has started how many hospitals have been built?  How many children found homes?  How many people found community?  How many non-profits established to serve the poor? How much beauty created?
There is much to confess.  I confess that the Church has often done a piss-poor job of being Christ’s body.  We have often been more about maintaining exclusionary practices than we have been about the transgressive beauty of the Gospel.  But we are still called to be members of one another, dying for the sake of the wold.  The church is still called to preach the Gospel and administer the sacraments.  If we don’t do it…who is?  The United Way?  The Elks Club?  Wall Mart?  Answer: no one.  That’s our job.
So…I believe in Religion AND Jesus.  I believe in the Gospel.  I believe in the transformative, knock you on your ass truth of what God has done in Christ.  I believe that I can only know what this following Jesus thing is about when I learn it from people I would never choose out of a catalog when we all gather together as the broken and blessed Body of Christ around the Eucharistic meal.  I believe that I am the problem at least as often as I am the solution. I believe in participating in sacred traditions that have a whole lot more integrity than anything I could come up with myself.  I believe I need someone else to proclaim the forgiveness of sins to me because I cannot create that for myself.  I believe that Jesus is truly present in the breaking of the bread and that where 2 or more are gathered he is there.   That’s religion AND Jesus.  May God make us worthy of it all.

09 February 2012

Barack Obama's Contraception Ruling Backed By Previously Unreleased Survey 9FEB12

REDEFINING RAPE, CALLOUSNES
­S ABOUT INCEST, INDIFFEREN­CE ABOUT THE HEALTH OF PREGNANT WOMEN, RESTRICTIO­NS ON ACCESS TO BIRTH CONTROL, all characteri­stics of the gop / tea-bagger­, Catholic bishops and evangelica­l right-wing extremist war against women. For the most part this war is being waged by men; men in congress, male presidenti­al wannabes, the male leadership of the Catholic church, the male leadership of extreme right wing evangelica­ls. Men who have no problem with VIAGRA being covered by health insurance plans. Men who want to keep women in their place; servile, subjugated­, obedient, basically barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen. They seek to impose a most unchristia­n "christian sharia" rule on society, especially on women. We can not allow them to succeed. Join the ACLU's campaign to support and defend Pres Obama's regulation­s on birth control (part of the Affordable Care Act) by clicking the link
https://se­cure.aclu.­org/site/A­dvocacy?cm­d=display&­page=UserA­ction&id=4­063&s_subs­rc=120208_­HHS_email
and sending a letter to your Rep and Senators in D.C. This from HuffPost......
WASHINGTON -- Hoping to hold the line on President Barack Obama's controversial contraception ruling, which requires most religiously affiliated employers to cover the costs of their employees' birth control, Democrats are passing around private polling data from last August showing that a majority of the country -- including Catholics -- actually favors the policy.
A Democratic source on Thursday morning sent over previously unreleased data put together by pollster Celinda Lake for the Herndon Alliance, a non-partisan pro-health care reform coalition. The survey, conducted with more than 1,000 people, focuses on all aspects of the Affordable Care Act.
Its release was not authorized by the Herndon Alliance. For the Democratic party, however, the poll serves an important function. It contained a series of questions that are highly relevant to the debate over whether religious-oriented institutions should be required to offer contraception as part of their health care plans.
The poll asks respondents to react to the following argument, the language of which seems fairly evenly phrased by the standards of the current debate.
"Requiring health insurers to cover contraceptives violates the rights of people who belong to religions that don't believe in artificial contraception. The Catholic Church morally opposes birth control and Orthodox Jews and some Protestants find birth control objectionable. Forcing religious groups, individuals, health providers, and health plans to perform or pay for a service that they may find morally objectionable is wrong."
According to the results, 42 percent of respondents found this argument convincing, but 52 percent were not convinced. The majority of respondents, then, didn't believe religious objections trumped employers' responsibility to cover contraceptives.
Further down in the survey are equally revealing numbers. The poll asked respondents to react to the fact that the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops "has sharply criticized the new rule requiring plans to cover contraception and birth control with no co-pays or deductible." Twenty percent said it made them view the Affordable Care Act less favorably, 18 percent said it made them view it more favorably, while a vast majority, 57 percent, said that it made no difference on their perception of the law at all. Those trend lines basically held when the respondents polled were only Catholics -- a full 53 percent said they weren't persuaded by the bishops.
Some of these results are driven by female respondents, who tend to be more supportive of contraception coverage requirements than men. But that hardly makes the data any less politically relevant. There is a perception that the administration's rule-making decision has opened it up to political disaster. The numbers don't necessarily reflect that.
Below is the full survey with the relevant data on pages 7 and 12.
contraception data
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/112557632/contraception-data 

The Republican War on Contraception from MOTHER JONES 9FEB12

REDEFINING RAPE, CALLOUSNESS ABOUT INCEST, INDIFFERENCE ABOUT THE HEALTH OF PREGNANT WOMEN, RESTRICTIONS ON ACCESS TO BIRTH CONTROL, all characteristics of the gop / tea-bagger, Catholic bishops and evangelical right-wing extremist war against women. For the most part this war is being waged by men; men in congress, male presidential wannabes, the male leadership of the Catholic church, the male leadership of extreme right wing evangelicals. Men who have no problem with VIAGRA being covered by health insurance plans. Men who want to keep women in their place; servile, subjugated, obedient, basically barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen. They seek to impose a most unchristian "christian sharia" rule on society, especially on women. We can not allow them to succeed. Join the ACLU's campaign to support and defend Pres Obama's regulations on birth control (part of the Affordable Care Act) by clicking the link
https://secure.aclu.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=4063&s_subsrc=120208_HHS_email 
and sending a letter to your Rep and Senators in D.C. This from Mother Jones......

The Republican War on Contraception

Not satisfied with restricting abortion rights, the GOP is now coming after your birth control.

discared birth control
Last year was not a great one for abortion rights. First, congressional Republicans attempted to deny statutory rape victims access to Medicaid-funded abortions (twice). Then GOP-dominated state legislatures pushed record numbers of laws limiting abortion rights, including proposals that could have treated killing abortion providers as "justifiable homicide."
Yet in the past six months, social conservatives have widened their offensive, and their new target is clear: Not satisfied with making it harder to obtain legal abortions, they want to limit access to birth control, too.
"Contraception is under attack in a way it really wasn't in the past few years," says Judy Waxman, the vice president for health and reproductive rights at the National Women's Law Center. "In 2004, we could not find any group—the National Right to Life Committee, the Bush campaign, anyone—that would go on the record to say they're opposed to birth control," adds Elizabeth Shipp, the political director for NARAL Pro-Choice America. "We couldn't find them in 2006 either, and in 2008 it was just fringe groups. In 2010, 2011, and this year, it's just exploded."
The first sign of the new assault came last October, when Mississippi activists and congressional Republicans pushed legislation on the state and federal level, respectively, that would have treated zygotes—a.k.a. fertilized human eggs—as legal "persons." If the definition of legal personhood is changed so that it begins when sperm meets an egg, hormonal birth control or barrier devices that prevent zygotes from implanting in the uterine wall could become illegal, making using an IUD tantamount to murder. Yet some 40 percent of House Republicans and a quarter of their allies in the Senate back bills that would do just that.
That's not all. Earlier this year, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), a rising conservative star who's considered a possible pick for the 2012 GOP vice-presidential nomination, introduced a bill that could cut off birth control access for millions of women by allowing even non-religious employers to refuse birth control coverage as long as they cite a religious reason. In other words, if your boss doesn't want to cover birth control in the company health plan because he says it would offend his religious beliefs, he wouldn't have to—even if his Cialis was still covered. Rubio's bill could also allow states to refuse to provide birth control through Medicaid, which provides family planning services to millions of poor women.
“These are people who have never, ever approved of birth control, and they saw an opportunity to take it one step further.”
The Republican presidential candidates also have come out against birth control. Mitt Romney has slammed President Barack Obama for requiring most employers to offer insurance that provides birth control at no cost to women who want it, even though Romney himself maintained a similar rule as governor of Massachusetts.
Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum, who won the non-binding Missouri primary as well as the Minnesota and Colorado caucuses on Tuesday, has also slammed Obama's decision. But he's also gone farther than that, suggesting that any form of birth control is immoral. "Many of the Christian faith have said, well, that's okay, contraception is okay," Santorum, a devout Catholic, said in October. "It's not okay. It's a license to do things in a sexual realm that is counter to how things are supposed to be." As Salon's Irin Carmon has documented, Santorum thinks Griswold v. Connecticut, the Supreme Court decision that said states can not deny married couples access to contraception, should be overturned.
Even previously uncontroversial ideas about contraception are now being questioned. As I explained in this story about Obama's birth-control policy, most of the administration's recently-issued rule requiring companies to provide birth control to their employees has been widely accepted federal law for a decade. Requiring employers to provide birth control if they provide other preventative services was so uncontroversial that most employers—even Catholic universities like DePaul, in Chicago—simply changed their policies and offered birth control to avoid being sued. The percentage of employers offering birth control coverage tripled in a decade. The national controversy only erupted after Obama issued the new rule in January.
NARAL's Shipp thinks the battlefield has definitely shifted. "First, everyone thought it was all about abortion access and abortion rights," she says. "But they decided to move the goalposts, and it's been kind of stunning how far to the right they've gone. These are people who have never, ever approved of birth control, and they saw an opportunity to take it one step further."
The White House probably isn't entirely unhappy with all the fighting over contraception. As the Washington Post's Sarah Kliff wrote, the birth control issue gives Obama's reelection campaign "a chance to widen the reproductive health debate beyond abortion" and energize young, secular abortion-rights supporters who might not otherwise vote.
Republicans who support abortion rights have warned their fellow GOPers that picking a fight over contraception could be a disaster. But even that hasn't slowed down the onslaught—on Wednesday, Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-Ohio), warned that he would soon push forward legislation that would allow employers to refuse to provide birth control to their employees. Boehner's Senate counterpart, Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), noted that several Republican senators have already introduced bills on the subject. One of those bills is Rubio's aforementioned Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
"I'm a little bit stunned with how far they have gone on birth control with absolutely no regard for the political consequences," Shipp continues. "Whether it's Rick Santorum, Mitt Romney—I don't think Newt Gingrich—if any of these guys think they're going to be able to come back to the middle after the attacks they've made on birth control, they're sadly mistaken, because the general public thinks they're just whack-a-doodle."

Nick Baumann

News Editor
Nick Baumann covers national politics and civil liberties issues for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. You can also follow him on Twitter and Facebook. Email tips and insights to nbaumann [at] motherjones [dot] com. RSS |

08 February 2012

Religious freedom or discrimination? & More Catholics support contraception coverage than other Americans 7FEB12 & Contraception Mandate, Five Reasons Why Obama Is Losing The Fight 8FEB12

THIS "religious war" being waged for the hearts and minds of the American electorate is a fabrication of the Catholic church and right wing religious extremist, using deception, manipulation and propaganda, methods Christ himself never had to use. The Obama administration is right in their decision to require religious affiliated public institutions to include birth control in the health insurance policies made available to their employees and they are also right in NOT requiring churches, synagogs, and mosques, to provide birth control to their employees if doing so violates the tenants of their faith. When one considers 98% of Catholics use birth control and 58% of Catholics, 68% of religiously unaffiliated Americans, 55% of all Americans, 62% of all women, 71% of Democrats and 51% of Independents all believe employer health plans should be required to provide free birth control coverage, it becomes obvious this "war" is nothing more than a propaganda campaign being waged by the male leadership of these religious groups for political gain, the subjugation of women and not religious rights and religious freedom. You can support the Obama administration and women's access to birth control by participating in the ACLU's campaign to pressure Congress and HHS not to revoke these new regulations here https://secure.aclu.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=4063&s_subsrc=120208_HHS_email 
Check out more on this action below, and the articles from Raw Story and Huffpost......
Because Freedom Can't Protect Itself 


Anti-choice forces around the country are yelling from the rooftops about religious freedom. But what they actually mean is the use of religion to discriminate and deny millions of women access to birth control.

Now anti-family planning politicians in Congress are getting in on the action and trying to reverse the President's critical decision, which would ensure access to birth control for millions of women.

We must stand with President Obama — believe me, he's hearing from the other side, starting with Speaker Boehner who has pledged to reverse this rule.

Tell your members of Congress: Stand up to right-wing efforts to use religion to discriminate and deny millions of women urgently needed access to birth control. 

Let's be clear. The current law does not require religious institutions like churches or synagogues to include birth control in their employee's health insurance.

But, when lobbying groups — led by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops — insisted that the exemption be expanded to include religiously affiliated hospitals, universities and other institutions, jeopardizing coverage for millions of women, the Obama administration drew a line in the sand.

If the lobbying groups get their way, a woman teaching at a Catholic university could not get coverage. Or, a nurse working at an evangelical Christian hospital could be denied access to basic health care.

Tell Congress to stand with the President and American women.

Anti-choice forces are screaming that the Obama administration's efforts to protect women's access to birth control are part of a "war on religion." This explosive accusation is untrue but their hope is that if they repeat it often enough, they can get Congress to roll back our rights. We can't let that happen.

Religious freedom is about protecting people of all faiths, not imposing the values of some on the rest of us.

Thank you for acting quickly in this critical moment,


Laura W. Murphy
Director, Washington Legislative Office



© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10004


More Catholics support contraception coverage than other Americans


U.S. Catholics support birth control/contraception (Shutterstock)
 http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/02/07/more-catholics-support-contraception-coverage-than-other-americans/
Catholics in the U.S. are more likely that other Americans say that employers should be required to provide insurance that covers free contraception, according to a recent poll.
A survey released by the Public Religion Research Institute on Tuesday found that 58 percent of Catholics think businesses should be required to provide health plans with free birth control, compared with 55 percent of all Americans who agreed with the requirement. At 38 percent, white evangelical protestants were the least likely to agree free contraception should be provided by employers.
Religiously unaffiliated Americans, at 68 percent, were the most likely say that company health plans should cover birth control for free.
Among political parties, 73 percent of Democrats and 51 percent of independents said health insurance should include free birth control. But only 36 percent of Republicans agreed with that point of view.
The poll also uncovered a significant gender gap. Overall, 62 percent of women said contraception should be provided at no cost, while only 47 percent of men thought it should be a requirement.
In recent weeks, a controversy has erupted over the issue of employers being required to provide birth control coverage, with Catholic leaders and many conservative politicians taking the view that it should be optional.
The Obama administration announced last month it would stand by a policy that requires virtually all private insurance policies to cover family planning, including female contraceptives, essentially guaranteeing near universal access to birth control once all the provisions of the Affordable Care Act are implemented.
Last week, thousands of Catholic parishioners were read letters by Catholic Bishops in the U.S. that condemned the Obama administration for that decision.
“We cannot — we will not — comply with this unjust law,” Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted wrote in just one of the numerous letters. “People of faith cannot be made second class citizens. We are already joined by our brothers and sisters of all faiths and many others of good will in this important effort to regain our religious freedom. Our parents and grandparents did not come to these shores to help build America’s cities and towns, its infrastructure and institutions, its enterprise and culture, only to have their posterity stripped of their God given rights.”
David Axelrod, a top adviser to President Barack Obama’s re-election campaign, suggested on Tuesday that the administration was open to working with Catholic hospitals and universities over their objections to providing birth control services to women.

Contraception Mandate, Five Reasons Why Obama Is Losing The Fight
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/08/obama-contraception-losing-fight_n_1263919.html 
By David Gibson
Religion News Service

(RNS) The White House has surprised observers and disappointed some liberal allies by signaling that it is willing to compromise and provide a broader religious exemption in its controversial regulations requiring all employers to provide free contraception coverage.
Given that birth control use is almost universal -- even among Catholics -- many wonder why the Obama administration could wind up retreating on its pledge.
Here are five reasons that may help explain the political dynamic the president is facing:
1. It's about religious freedom, not birth control
U.S. Catholic bishops, who led the battle against the Health and Human Services Department mandate, know that they long ago lost their own flock on the contraception issue -- 98 percent of Catholics use birth control, according to surveys.
So they have carefully reframed the issue as a fight for religious freedom -- an effort to keep the government from forcing the Catholic Church and other religious groups to subsidize something that goes against their teachings. That makes it a violation of conscience, a sacred principle that transcends any specific tenet of faith.
That argument also lends itself to the kind of heated rhetoric that plays well in today's supercharged political atmosphere. For example, bishops and their allies are accusing the president of "anti-Catholicism" and worse: "The Obama administration has just told the Catholics of the United States, 'To hell with you!'" Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik said after the HHS regulations were announced.
The bishops don't have as much credibility with the laity as they used to, thanks to the clergy sex abuse scandal, among other things. But Catholics are still a potent tribe, and if outsiders are seen as attacking the church, Catholics can get defensive -- and they can get even.
2. Obama has lost even the support of his liberal Catholic allies
Case in point: the HHS mandate has been opposed by liberal and centrist Catholics who have supported the administration on a range of other issues -- including the Catholic Health Association and the NETWORK social justice lobby -- and even went to bat to help pass health care reform despite threats from the bishops.
The president "utterly botched" the religious exemptions issue, wrote Washington Post columnist and liberal Catholic E.J. Dionne, and "Obama threw his progressive Catholic allies under the bus."
"J'accuse!" Michael Sean Winters, a columnist for the liberal National Catholic Reporter, wrote in a florid column that channeled Emile Zola's famous 1898 letter accusing the French government of anti-Semitism in the Dreyfus affair. "The issue of conscience protections is so foundational, I do not see how I ever could, in good conscience, vote for this man again."
3. It's not just Catholics
Even though evangelicals and other conservative Protestants generally don't have religious objections to contraception, they do have a big problem with "big government" and with perceived infringements on religious freedom.
Evangelicals -- both their leaders and their troops -- have never been big Barack Obama supporters anyway, so they were happy to provide any electoral and rhetorical muscle the Catholic hierarchy could not muster.
"We do not exaggerate when we say that this is the greatest threat to religious freedom in our lifetime," evangelical leaders Timothy George and Chuck Colson wrote in an open letter to their fellow believers on Wednesday (Feb. 8). George and Colson compared the administration mandates to policies enacted in Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler.
4. It gives Republicans a potent campaign wedge issue
Mitt Romney wasted no time in accusing Obama of launching an "assault on religion" by way of the contraception mandate, and he declared that his first act as president would be to overturn the HHS regulations. "Remarkably, under this president's administration, there is an assault on religion, an assault on the conviction and the religious beliefs of members of our society," Romney said.
Romney's rivals, Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum, were not to be outdone, and ramped up their rhetoric against Obama -- while also noting that Romney had accepted similar policies while he was governor of Massachusetts.
In short, this is a political fight that the White House neither wants nor needs in an already tough re-election campaign.
5. Obama needs the Catholic vote
In particular, he needs the support of white Catholics, which is the core of this large swing vote (nearly one-quarter of the electorate). They are concentrated in crucial battleground states like Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania, and while Obama won the overall Catholic vote 54 percent to 46 percent in 2008, he lost the white Catholic vote, 47 percent to 53 percent.
"To the extent Catholic voters think of this as a religious liberty issue, it does have the potential to pull Catholic voters toward Republicans or away from Democrats," John Green, an expert on religious voting patterns and director of the University of Akron's Ray C. Bliss Institute of Applied Politics, told Bloomberg Businessweek.
A poll on the contraception mandate released Tuesday by the Public Religion Research Institute showed Catholics overall tended to support free contraceptive coverage, but white Catholics were evenly split on the issue. The Obama campaign can't afford to sacrifice any of those votes, or risk watching the issue grow as a political liability when the election season heats up.