THIS article contains warnings for America. Warnings not about threat is hard line Islamist ruling Tunisia, but about the extreme right wing agenda, allegedly rooted in Christianity and the intent of our Founding Fathers, being legislated in communities and states and even at the federal level. Restrictions on access to birth control and safe, legal abortions, restrictions on voting rights, restrictions on free speech and freedom of expression by nonviolent protest, restrictions on construction of houses of worship and expansion of government surveillance all represent an assault on and erosion of basic American civil liberties, civil rights, human rights and the rule of law. The only difference between what is happening in the U.S. and in Tunisia and other newly liberated Arab countries is the religion of the extremist. Christian or Islamist, they are all perverting the true teachings of their faiths to impose the narrow minded beliefs of a minority on the majority. They are not representatives of democracy but of repressive theocracy, a serious threat to basic human rights in America and in Tunisia, Libya, Egypt and Yemen. This from the Washington Post....
By Marc Fisher,
Tunis — Outside the courthouse, 16 armed police officers screen all
comers, including hundreds of lawyers in flowing black robes. Beyond a
wall of barbed wire, a throng of bearded young men angrily shout
slogans. The scene sends a clear message: Could be trouble here.
The subject of all this attention is a short, hyperactive,
wise-cracking TV mogul who smokes fat stogies, has 25 bodyguards on his
payroll and is on trial over charges of libeling Islam.
Nabil Karoui owns the HBO of Tunisia, a satellite TV channel called Nessma (“Breeze”) that shows Hollywood movies and TV series.
A
week before Tunisians voted in the fall for their first freely elected
government since 1956, Nessma aired the French-language animated movie “Persepolis,”
based on an Iranian exile’s graphic novel about a girl who comes of age
during Iran’s 1979 revolution. In the weeks after the broadcast,
Karoui’s house was destroyed by a mob of vandals and Nessma’s offices
were repeatedly attacked — all because of a short scene in which the
girl imagines herself talking to God, who appears as an old man with a
long, white beard.
Now, Karoui’s on trial,
and so is Tunisia’s year-old revolution and the young democracy it has
wrought. For hundreds of years, Tunisia has boasted a complex blend of
Islamic and Western values, and now, having ousted their autocratic
leader, Tunisians are struggling to find the right balance. No part of
that wrenching, sometimes violent debate has been more divisive than the
issue of freedom of speech.
Last month, on this capital city’s
main boulevard, Islamist activists attacked actors who were celebrating
World Theater Day; Islamists smashed musical instruments and hurled
eggs. A hard-line preacher stood in front of Tunis’s Grand Synagogue and
called for the murder of Tunisian Jews. And a Tunisian philosopher who
showed up at a TV station for a debate on Islam was shouted down by
extremists, who said he was no scholar of the faith because he has no
beard.
In each case, calls for a state crackdown on offensive
speech banged up against cries for the government to defend even
unpopular expression. Karoui’s day in court became a nonstop, seven-hour
shoutfest that will determine whether he is fined, imprisoned, or
worse. A verdict is expected Thursday.
In Tunisia, defendants hire
a lawyer, but any lawyer in the land may join the prosecution or
defense, and those lawyers have the same right to argue in court as
hired attorneys. The result: a pulsating black mass of robed men (and a
handful of women) surging to the front of Courtroom 10, each with his
own view of what should be done to Karoui.
Shouldn’t the death
penalty be considered, asks lawyer Nasser Saidi: “Anything related to
God is absolute. This was a test of the Tunisian people’s ability to
defend God, and they have passed the test.”
No, five years max,
says Karoui’s chief attorney, Omar Labiadh. But how can this case even
be in court, he asks. Before the revolution, he says, “ ‘Persepolis’ was
broadcast at least five times on Tunisian TV.”
The two sides
argue as if they live in different galaxies. They cite different laws —
God’s and man’s. They base their arguments on different histories —
Western traditions of transparency and individual rights vs. Islamic
concepts of Koranic authority and the obligations of the community of
believers.
“These lawyers who speak against Karoui have no right
to base a case on public opinion,” says Karoui attorney Faouzi Ben Mrad.
To prosecute someone just for violating a religious commandment would
be folly, Mrad says. For example, Mohammed Bouazizi, who sparked the
Tunisian revolution by burning himself to death, “committed a sin by
committing suicide. Now he is the symbol of our revolution. Are you
going to prosecute him, too? This is Tunisia, not Kandahar or Pakistan.
From Carthage to Mohammed Bouazizi, Tunisia has a different history.”
‘It was hysteria, craziness’
Karoui thought
he had problems under the old regime. Tunisia’s longtime despot, Zine
el-Abidine Ben Ali, refused permission for a privately owned channel to
compete against state TV, so Karoui launched Nessma as a pirate station,
without a license. His billboards were defaced and his advertisers
harassed.
When Karoui finally won the right to broadcast from
Tunisia, he played it safe, steering clear of political content and
focusing on sports, television series such as “House” and music. But
when the revolution broke out about 17 months ago, Karoui defied Ben
Ali’s ban on political programming and switched to an all-news format.
Today, he has a mix of programs, a news staff
of 50 and a clear position: “We are modernists, not Islamists,” he
says. “We oppose sharia law and four wives. We show decolletage and
miniskirts, and the extremists hack our Web site to retaliate.”
Karoui,
48, offers programs that put a Western face on Tunisia — and draw big
ratings. “What we show, young people would watch even if we didn’t show
it, but they’d watch it on HBO or the French channels,” he says. “Our
vision is to push the country to be more modernist, but we understand
the limits — no nudity, because this is a Muslim country.”
The
decision to air “Persepolis” was very much about sending a message,
Karoui says. He saw the story of the Iranian revolution as a cautionary
tale for Tunisians “because every day in Iran, the Islamists took away
one piece of freedom, and after two years of that, they took over the
country.”
Before “Persepolis” aired, Karoui’s standards director
glanced over a few minutes of the film and said, “It’s okay, it’s a
cartoon.” The movie aired and got a lousy rating, no more than 50,000
viewers.
But as soon as the broadcast began, Nessma’s Facebook
page filled with rants calling the station traitorous and attacking
Karoui as a Jew and a Mason, neither of which he is. Two days later, 500
protesters arrived at the studios, threatening to burn the building.
“It
was hysteria, craziness,” says Karoui, who watched from his top-floor
office as protesters pushed toward his front door. “I understand that
some people were offended, but please: No one watched the movie!”
Karoui
went on Nessma to apologize to anyone who was offended, but on the
following Friday, clerics at some mosques urged worshipers to take their
anger to Nessma’s office. Police told Karoui that they could not
protect him and urged him to go into hiding.
The next day,
Karoui’s house was firebombed and trashed. “I had nothing left — no art,
no furniture, no glassware,” he says. Fourteen attackers were arrested
and fined $6 each.
Karoui has had to build a safe room in his house, stocked with a week’s worth of food.
“It’s
very weird: I’m a Muslim, I fast on Ramadan, but I can’t go to mosque
with my father and my son,” Karoui says. “I have 100 videos of religious
leaders saying, ‘You must kill Karoui, cut off his right hand and take
his eyes out.’ And the crazy thing is, I’m still optimistic about my
country.”
Ruling coalition in a bind
The moderate Islamist party that leads Tunisia’s new governing
coalition would like the Karoui case and others like it to go away.
“It’s very difficult to put in place red lines on freedom of speech,”
says Rachid Ghannouchi, spiritual leader of the Ennahda party.
“Boundaries are set by society, and society changes. We are free to
believe what we want, but we are not free to speak against others’
beliefs.”
Ghannouchi says he thinks Karoui intentionally aired
“Persepolis” just before the elections to provoke violence by Islamist
extremists, thereby sullying the image of all Islamists. “But we didn’t
fall into this trap,” he says. “We defended his freedom of speech and
said there should be no prison sentence.”
That position does not
sit well with more hard-line Islamists, who want the state to silence
Nessma and punish what they view as hate speech.
“Each country has
its own view of free expression,” says Rafik Ghaki, a 33-year-old
lawyer who heads a coalition of ultraconservative Islamists known as
Salafists. “We do not oppose free expression, but it must have limits to
protect the beliefs of others. We are for freedom, but an organized
freedom.”
Ghaki argued against Karoui in court and organized a
street protest last month against a Tunisian man alleged to have flushed
pages from the Koran down the toilet.
That protest collapsed into violence, as Salafists attacked a crowd of actors celebrating World Theater Day down the street.
“The
problem is there is no communication between these two parts of
society,” Ghaki says. “We have youth in a new movement, and some of them
get overexcited. And then some of the elite is against religion and
Islam.”
It would be a mistake to expect Islamists to accept
Western notions of free speech, Ghaki says: Airing “Persepolis” “in a
very unstable period is not a patriotic act. As a civilized person, if
that happens, I will go to the law for redress.”
Courtroom shoutfest
In Courtroom 10, anti-Karoui lawyer Seifeddine Makhlouf thunders
against the audacity of those who defend the broadcast of an image of
God: “Am I defending God here? Yes, because the Koran says if you
support God, He will support you.”
After three hours of such arguments against Karoui, his defenders get their turn. They, too, speak of God’s will.
“You
arrogantly claim to defend God,” roars defender Mourad Selimi. “No one
can defend God. He defends himself. No, this case must be dismissed.
This case will determine whether a revolution really happened here.”
But
by this point, the lawyers on the other side have left the room;
Karoui’s defenders shout only to one another and the judges, who stare
impassively, silent amid the cacophony of freedom.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/tunisian-court-case-exposes-rift-over-free-speech-in-new-democracy/2012/05/02/gIQAj4cexT_print.html
NORTON META TAG
Showing posts with label Mohamed Bouazizi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mohamed Bouazizi. Show all posts
17 February 2011
Tunis renames square after man who sparked protests 17FEB11
LET'S hope and pray the new government is able to work with the people for real democratic reforms that honor the sacrifices of this man and the others killed in the revolution by the former government.
Tunisian authorities renamed the main square in the capital Tunis after a vegetable seller whose suicide sparked the protests that toppled the regime.
The newly named Mohammad Bouazizi Square had previously been November 7 Square, marking the date in 1987 when former President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali took power.
Bouazizi set himself on fire in December when police confiscated his goods and scales -- a desperate act that launched a wave of protests that led Ben Ali to flee to Saudi Arabia in January and inspired the uprising in Egypt that led President Hosni Mubarak to step down.
The renaming was announced on Thursday by Tunis municipality.
Tunisian authorities renamed the main square in the capital Tunis after a vegetable seller whose suicide sparked the protests that toppled the regime.
The newly named Mohammad Bouazizi Square had previously been November 7 Square, marking the date in 1987 when former President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali took power.
Bouazizi set himself on fire in December when police confiscated his goods and scales -- a desperate act that launched a wave of protests that led Ben Ali to flee to Saudi Arabia in January and inspired the uprising in Egypt that led President Hosni Mubarak to step down.
The renaming was announced on Thursday by Tunis municipality.
20 January 2011
Tunisia's Leaders Resign From Ruling Party 20JAN11
IT is thrilling to see the Tunisian people maintaining the pressure on the acting government to guarantee the revolution was for nothing. Democracy first in Tunisia, will freedom spread to Algeria, Egypt, Libya.....and farther? AMERICANS need to pay attention to the events in Tunisia if for no other reason than to remind us that we need to appreciate our freedom and that DEMOCRACY IS NOT A SPECTATOR SPORT! From NPR.....
All of Tunisia's government ministers who belonged to the longtime ruling party quit their memberships Thursday in a bid to distance themselves from the country's ousted president and quell unrest in the capital, where the army fired warning shots to break up protests.
Demonstrators converged on the RCD party headquarters in central Tunis, dismantling the sign bearing its name and carrying off pieces of its letters. Outside the gates, the army fired about 10 rounds into the air, scattering some protesters in the noisy but peaceful crowd.
While police repeatedly shot at protesters in the weeks leading up to Ben Ali's ouster, killing several, the army has been playing more of a peacekeeping role since it was brought in to try to restore order last week.
Thursday's crowd of protesters swelled to about 2,000 people, many chanting "The people want the government down!" Others waved baguettes to symbolize the need to end food shortages.
One father, Ahmad al-Ouni, brought his children ages 8 and 4 to the demonstration with a backpack of snacks and juice. "I want them to smell their free country and to see the new Tunis without fear," al-Ouni said while his children used colored pens to draw Tunisian flags on paper.
Critics say the country's new government is too stacked with Cabinet officials who were allied with autocratic President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, who was forced out last week after 23 years in power. One demonstrator said the street protests will continue until all ministers and members of parliament with links to the RCD are removed from power.
"This revolution cannot be stolen from us and we will not tire from demonstrating, and we will come out every day if we have to," said Mohsen Kaabi, 55, a former military officer.
All eight Cabinet ministers who belonged to the party relinquished their affiliations Thursday, the official TAP news agency said. The attempts to pacify public anger come a day after similar moves by Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi and interim President Fouad Mebazaa.
The interim government also has released all of the country's political prisoners to ease the tensions.
Even so, it remained unclear whether the latest concessions could assuage the popular anger that deposed Ben Ali and is now directed at the caretaker government.
"We're in a critical period now, but we're going to come through it," protester Bessim Zitouni, 28, told NPR. "Tunisians have great solidarity. And that will see us through. I know we're going to have a great future."
State media reported that at least 33 members of Ben Ali's family have been taken into custody as they tried to flee the country for alleged "crimes against Tunisia."
"Investigations will be carried out in order for them to face justice," according to a statement read on national television.
Prosecutors have also said they are investigating overseas bank accounts, real estate and other assets held by Ben Ali and his wife, Leila Trabelsi, along with other relatives.
Swiss officials froze all assets tied to Ben Ali's family on Wednesday, estimating that Tunisian officials have put about $620 million into Swiss banks. In Paris, the watchdog group Transparency International France and two other associations filed a lawsuit alleging corruption by Ben Ali and Trabelsi, who fled to Saudi Arabia after his ouster.
Saudi Arabia, meanwhile, has set conditions for Ben Ali to remain in exile there.
Foreign Minister Prince Saud al Faisal said no political activity of any kind will be allowed and affirmed the kingdom's support for the Tunisian people. The Tunisian revolt has wide support in the Arab world, especially with Saudi Arabia's young blogging community — which was highly critical of the government's decision to offer safe haven to Ben Ali.
U.N. human rights chief Navanethem Pillay said Thursday that she planned to send a team to Tunisia to assess the human rights situation. She said at least 100 people have been killed in the unrest.
"Human rights abuses were at the heart of Tunisia's problems," Pillay said. "Therefore human rights must be right at the forefront of the solutions to those problems."
With reporting from Lisa Schlein in Geneva and NPR's Eleanor Beardsley in Tunis and Deborah Amos in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Material from The Associated Press was used in this report
by NPR Staff and Wires
Enlarge Martin Bureau/Getty Images A protester holds a placard reading "RCD Out" during a demonstration outside the headquarters of ousted Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali's Constitutional Democratic Rally party in central Tunis.
Martin Bureau/Getty Images
A protester holds a placard reading "RCD Out" during a demonstration outside the headquarters of ousted Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali's Constitutional Democratic Rally party in central Tunis.
Source: NPR
Credit: Alyson Hurt
Credit: Alyson Hurt
Demonstrators converged on the RCD party headquarters in central Tunis, dismantling the sign bearing its name and carrying off pieces of its letters. Outside the gates, the army fired about 10 rounds into the air, scattering some protesters in the noisy but peaceful crowd.
While police repeatedly shot at protesters in the weeks leading up to Ben Ali's ouster, killing several, the army has been playing more of a peacekeeping role since it was brought in to try to restore order last week.
Thursday's crowd of protesters swelled to about 2,000 people, many chanting "The people want the government down!" Others waved baguettes to symbolize the need to end food shortages.
One father, Ahmad al-Ouni, brought his children ages 8 and 4 to the demonstration with a backpack of snacks and juice. "I want them to smell their free country and to see the new Tunis without fear," al-Ouni said while his children used colored pens to draw Tunisian flags on paper.
Critics say the country's new government is too stacked with Cabinet officials who were allied with autocratic President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, who was forced out last week after 23 years in power. One demonstrator said the street protests will continue until all ministers and members of parliament with links to the RCD are removed from power.
"This revolution cannot be stolen from us and we will not tire from demonstrating, and we will come out every day if we have to," said Mohsen Kaabi, 55, a former military officer.
All eight Cabinet ministers who belonged to the party relinquished their affiliations Thursday, the official TAP news agency said. The attempts to pacify public anger come a day after similar moves by Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi and interim President Fouad Mebazaa.
The interim government also has released all of the country's political prisoners to ease the tensions.
What Is The Jasmine Revolution?
Weeks of protests driven by rising food prices, unemployment and complaints about corruption drove Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali to flee the country for Saudi Arabia on Jan. 14 — after 23 years in power.
The immediate trigger for the violent protests was the self-immolation on Dec. 17 of Mohamed Bouazizi, a university graduate who had been unable to find work. After being harassed by police for selling vegetables from a cart, Bouazizi set himself ablaze.
Since Ben Ali's departure, Tunisia has cycled through new leaders rapidly, with power changing between two new chiefs of state in the first 24 hours. On Jan. 17, interim Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi formed a unity government that included figures from opposition parties. But four opposition ministers stepped down a day later, bowing to protesters angry that the government still included officials from Democratic Constitutional Rally, Ben Ali's party, which has ruled Tunisia since it gained independence in 1956.
Tunisia's so-called Jasmine Revolution has sparked debate about whether Ben Ali's departure will lead to regime change elsewhere in the Arab world. Thus far, there are no serious signs of calls for change in neighboring countries, although there have been self-immolations in Egypt, Mauritania and Algeria, as well as demonstrations elsewhere.
— Alan Greenblatt
The immediate trigger for the violent protests was the self-immolation on Dec. 17 of Mohamed Bouazizi, a university graduate who had been unable to find work. After being harassed by police for selling vegetables from a cart, Bouazizi set himself ablaze.
Since Ben Ali's departure, Tunisia has cycled through new leaders rapidly, with power changing between two new chiefs of state in the first 24 hours. On Jan. 17, interim Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi formed a unity government that included figures from opposition parties. But four opposition ministers stepped down a day later, bowing to protesters angry that the government still included officials from Democratic Constitutional Rally, Ben Ali's party, which has ruled Tunisia since it gained independence in 1956.
Tunisia's so-called Jasmine Revolution has sparked debate about whether Ben Ali's departure will lead to regime change elsewhere in the Arab world. Thus far, there are no serious signs of calls for change in neighboring countries, although there have been self-immolations in Egypt, Mauritania and Algeria, as well as demonstrations elsewhere.
— Alan Greenblatt
"We're in a critical period now, but we're going to come through it," protester Bessim Zitouni, 28, told NPR. "Tunisians have great solidarity. And that will see us through. I know we're going to have a great future."
State media reported that at least 33 members of Ben Ali's family have been taken into custody as they tried to flee the country for alleged "crimes against Tunisia."
"Investigations will be carried out in order for them to face justice," according to a statement read on national television.
Prosecutors have also said they are investigating overseas bank accounts, real estate and other assets held by Ben Ali and his wife, Leila Trabelsi, along with other relatives.
Swiss officials froze all assets tied to Ben Ali's family on Wednesday, estimating that Tunisian officials have put about $620 million into Swiss banks. In Paris, the watchdog group Transparency International France and two other associations filed a lawsuit alleging corruption by Ben Ali and Trabelsi, who fled to Saudi Arabia after his ouster.
Saudi Arabia, meanwhile, has set conditions for Ben Ali to remain in exile there.
Foreign Minister Prince Saud al Faisal said no political activity of any kind will be allowed and affirmed the kingdom's support for the Tunisian people. The Tunisian revolt has wide support in the Arab world, especially with Saudi Arabia's young blogging community — which was highly critical of the government's decision to offer safe haven to Ben Ali.
U.N. human rights chief Navanethem Pillay said Thursday that she planned to send a team to Tunisia to assess the human rights situation. She said at least 100 people have been killed in the unrest.
"Human rights abuses were at the heart of Tunisia's problems," Pillay said. "Therefore human rights must be right at the forefront of the solutions to those problems."
With reporting from Lisa Schlein in Geneva and NPR's Eleanor Beardsley in Tunis and Deborah Amos in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Material from The Associated Press was used in this report
Related NPR Stories
With Former Leader Out, Tunisians Speak Freely Jan. 20, 2011
Tunisia's Acting President Vows To Break From Past Jan. 19, 2011
Foreign Policy: What Went Wrong In Tunisia Jan. 18, 2011
Tunisia's Days-Old Government Shows Cracks Jan. 18, 2011
Tunisia Forms New Government Amid Protests Jan. 17, 2011
15 January 2011
Twelve hours that shook Tunisia, trapped in my hotel room 15JAN11
MORE on the revolution in Tunisia, this from Amnesty International.......
By Diana Eltahawy in Tunis, Amnesty International researcher for North Africa
While I was making hectic last minute preparations to travel to Tunisia as part of an Amnesty International delegation looking into human rights violations, in the context of the social unrest that has shaken the country since late last year, a colleague joked that I would be sitting in a hotel room in Tunis watching developments on Al Jazeera. While we laughed it off at the time, the prophesy proved to be somewhat true.
From the moment of my arrival on Friday 14 January, I could feel that Tunisia was a different country. Unlike the norm during previous Amnesty International fact-finding visits, we were not followed by security forces from the airport. It was clear that their concerns were far beyond obstructing an Amnesty International report criticising the country’s appalling human rights record.
About two hours after our arrival, the Tunis airport and airspace were shut down, apparently by the army. After that, events unfolded with incredible speed.
A demonstration in front of the Ministry of Interior was violently dispersed; President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali dismissed the government; and Tunisian television announced the imposition of a nation-wide state of emergency and a curfew between 5pm and 7am until further notice.
While trapped in the hotel room waiting for the much anticipated announcement promised on Tunisian television, we were overwhelmed by a slew of rumours: the army had taken over, Ben Ali had left the country, and his wife’s family had been arrested by security forces while trying to flee the country. Some of them proved true – the jury is still out on others.
As frustrating as it is to be so close to historical events, and yet so removed in a hotel room, I still got a sense of the momentous occasion.
I could see smoke rising from the centre of Tunis.
I could hear shots in the distance.
I could hear people whistling and clapping inside their homes when it was announced that Ben Ali had relinquished power, and that the Prime Minister, Mohamed Ghannouchi, had initially assumed the functions of the President until elections are held within six months (the speaker of the Tunisian parliament has since become the acting president).
Outside my hotel window I saw empty, still streets. At about 10pm, an army vehicle drove by. An hour and a half later, I could hear helicopters circling above.
Before the imposition of the curfew, we had the opportunity to meet journalists gathered at the press syndicate. Most of them had just returned from the protest in front of the Ministry of Interior.
They told us that security forces had fired tear gas at protestors and beat some of them. They complained about the official media blackout and the arrests of some of their colleagues. They expressed sympathy to the dozens of protestors who have been shot by security forces across Tunisia in the past few weeks.
One said that Ben Ali had survived for 23 years through the repression of freedom of expression. Today though, they openly engaged in an animated and candid debate on the future of their country without fear.
After two decades of ruthless repression in the name of security, Tunisians will be expecting the Tunisian authorities to finally begin to uphold the human rights which they have spent so long restricting.
Amnesty International has spent decades documenting abuses by the Tunisian security forces, including arbitrary arrest and detention, torture, and flagrantly unfair trials.
The Tunisian authorities have also ruthlessly cracked down on dissenting voices. Political opposition has been crushed, independent civil society organizations have been denied legal registration, or have been subject to “coups” by government supporters. Human rights defenders, lawyers or journalists have faced surveillance and intimidation on a daily basis.
Security forces, in particular the feared “police politique”, controlled so many aspects of Tunisians’ lives.
It remains to be seen whether this new start for Tunisia will lead to old abuses being brought to account.
While Tunisia’s future remains unpredictable, it is certain that the uprising has dramatically altered the face of Tunisian politics.
Its impact will no doubt be felt across the region – where other political systems survive through the repression of dissent with an iron fist and total disregard of human rights, as shown by small demonstrations in Cairo this evening calling for the resignation of President Hosni Mubarak, in power since 1981.
It is difficult to believe that events unleashed in December by the desperate and tragic act of Mohamed Bouazizi, setting himself on fire after police confiscated his fruit and vegetable stall, lead to the departure of Ben Ali, in power for two decades, from Tunisia less than a month later.
On 5 January, Mohamed Bouazizi succumbed to his injuries; but he will certainly be immortalized in modern Tunisian history. Ben Ali’s legacy is less clear, particularly in light of rising calls for his prosecution for human rights violations committed during his rule.
While I was making hectic last minute preparations to travel to Tunisia as part of an Amnesty International delegation looking into human rights violations, in the context of the social unrest that has shaken the country since late last year, a colleague joked that I would be sitting in a hotel room in Tunis watching developments on Al Jazeera. While we laughed it off at the time, the prophesy proved to be somewhat true.
From the moment of my arrival on Friday 14 January, I could feel that Tunisia was a different country. Unlike the norm during previous Amnesty International fact-finding visits, we were not followed by security forces from the airport. It was clear that their concerns were far beyond obstructing an Amnesty International report criticising the country’s appalling human rights record.
About two hours after our arrival, the Tunis airport and airspace were shut down, apparently by the army. After that, events unfolded with incredible speed.
A demonstration in front of the Ministry of Interior was violently dispersed; President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali dismissed the government; and Tunisian television announced the imposition of a nation-wide state of emergency and a curfew between 5pm and 7am until further notice.
While trapped in the hotel room waiting for the much anticipated announcement promised on Tunisian television, we were overwhelmed by a slew of rumours: the army had taken over, Ben Ali had left the country, and his wife’s family had been arrested by security forces while trying to flee the country. Some of them proved true – the jury is still out on others.
As frustrating as it is to be so close to historical events, and yet so removed in a hotel room, I still got a sense of the momentous occasion.
I could see smoke rising from the centre of Tunis.
I could hear shots in the distance.
I could hear people whistling and clapping inside their homes when it was announced that Ben Ali had relinquished power, and that the Prime Minister, Mohamed Ghannouchi, had initially assumed the functions of the President until elections are held within six months (the speaker of the Tunisian parliament has since become the acting president).
Outside my hotel window I saw empty, still streets. At about 10pm, an army vehicle drove by. An hour and a half later, I could hear helicopters circling above.
Before the imposition of the curfew, we had the opportunity to meet journalists gathered at the press syndicate. Most of them had just returned from the protest in front of the Ministry of Interior.
They told us that security forces had fired tear gas at protestors and beat some of them. They complained about the official media blackout and the arrests of some of their colleagues. They expressed sympathy to the dozens of protestors who have been shot by security forces across Tunisia in the past few weeks.
One said that Ben Ali had survived for 23 years through the repression of freedom of expression. Today though, they openly engaged in an animated and candid debate on the future of their country without fear.
After two decades of ruthless repression in the name of security, Tunisians will be expecting the Tunisian authorities to finally begin to uphold the human rights which they have spent so long restricting.
Amnesty International has spent decades documenting abuses by the Tunisian security forces, including arbitrary arrest and detention, torture, and flagrantly unfair trials.
The Tunisian authorities have also ruthlessly cracked down on dissenting voices. Political opposition has been crushed, independent civil society organizations have been denied legal registration, or have been subject to “coups” by government supporters. Human rights defenders, lawyers or journalists have faced surveillance and intimidation on a daily basis.
Security forces, in particular the feared “police politique”, controlled so many aspects of Tunisians’ lives.
It remains to be seen whether this new start for Tunisia will lead to old abuses being brought to account.
While Tunisia’s future remains unpredictable, it is certain that the uprising has dramatically altered the face of Tunisian politics.
Its impact will no doubt be felt across the region – where other political systems survive through the repression of dissent with an iron fist and total disregard of human rights, as shown by small demonstrations in Cairo this evening calling for the resignation of President Hosni Mubarak, in power since 1981.
It is difficult to believe that events unleashed in December by the desperate and tragic act of Mohamed Bouazizi, setting himself on fire after police confiscated his fruit and vegetable stall, lead to the departure of Ben Ali, in power for two decades, from Tunisia less than a month later.
On 5 January, Mohamed Bouazizi succumbed to his injuries; but he will certainly be immortalized in modern Tunisian history. Ben Ali’s legacy is less clear, particularly in light of rising calls for his prosecution for human rights violations committed during his rule.
Unrest Engulfs Tunisia; President Flees 15JAN11
I have been listening to (on NPR) and reading and watching (on PBS) the events of the past week in Tunisia, dismayed by the violence of the government against their own people, and very impressed with the Tunisian people's courage and their desire for freedom and their willingness, men and women, to sacrifice their lives to bring democracy and freedom to their country. NPR's Eleanor Beardsley's reporting from Tunis during the revolt was riveting, her interviews with Tunisians on the streets allowed us to hear the dreams and desires for freedom from the people...I love this picture of the woman protester waving the Tunisian flag, her country's flag, in front of security forces at the Interior Ministry in Tunis......OH THAT WE WOULD REMEMBER JUST HOW PRECIOUS FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY ARE!!!! Check out the other NPR reports at the end of this post, click the links and listen to the Eleanor Beardsley's reporting....
Tunisia swore in a new interim president Saturday — the second change of power in this North African nation in less than 24 hours — and grappled with looting, deadly prison riots and chaos in the streets after protests forced the country's leader to flee.
Amid the political instability, looters emptied shops and torched the capital's main train station, and soldiers traded fire with assailants in front of the Interior Ministry in Tunis. At least 42 people were killed Saturday in a prison fire in a resort town and the director of another prison let 1,000 inmates flee after a deadly rebellion.
The interim president — Fouad Mebazaa, the former president of the lower house of parliament — ordered the creation of a unity government that could include the opposition, which had been frozen out and ignored under President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali's 23 years of autocratic rule.
Ben Ali abruptly fled the country Friday for Saudi Arabia following a month of street protests over corruption, a lack of jobs and clampdowns on civil liberties. Yet while the protests were mostly peaceful, the first day after his departure was chaotic — deadly.
The leadership changes came at a dizzying speed. After Ben Ali left, his longtime ally, Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi, stepped in briefly with a vague assumption of power that left open the possibility that Ben Ali could return. But on Saturday, Constitutional Council President Fethi Abdennadher declared the president's departure permanent and gave lawmaker Mebazaa 60 days in which to organize new elections.
Hours later, Mebazaa was sworn in.
In his first televised address, he said he asked the premier to form a "national unity government in the country's best interests'' in which all political parties will be consulted "without exception nor exclusion.''
The move was one of reconciliation, but it was not clear how far the 77-year-old Mebazaa, who has been part of Tunisia's ruling class for decades, would go to invite the opposition into the government.
It was also unclear who would emerge as the top political leaders in a post-Ben Ali Tunisia: The autocratic leader has utterly dominated politics for decades, placing his allies in power and sending opponents to jail or into exile.
On the streets, the unrest was frightening.
A fire at a prison in the Mediterranean coastal resort of Monastir killed 42 people, coroner Tarek Mghirbi told The Associated Press on Saturday. The cause of the fire was not immediately clear.
In Mahdia, farther down the coast, there was a rebellion inside a prison holding an estimated 1,000 prisoners, with inmates setting fire to their mattresses. Soldiers opened fire and five inmates were killed, a top local official said. The director of the prison let the inmates flee to avoid further bloodshed, the official said, asking not to be identified because of security concerns.
Security forces and unidentified assailants had a shootout Saturday in front of the Interior Ministry that left two bodies on the ground. It was not clear whether they were dead or who they are.
Sporadic gunfire echoed around in the capital on Saturday. Black smoke billowed over a giant supermarket as looters torched and emptied it. An Associated Press photographer saw soldiers fire warning shots and try to stop looters from sacking the supermarket in Ariana, north of the capital, to no avail. Shops near the main bazaar were also looted.
Public television station TV7 broadcast phone calls from residents of working-class neighborhoods on the capital's outskirts, describing attacks against their homes by knife-wielding assailants.
"This isn't good at all. I'm very afraid for the kids and myself,'' said Lilia Ben Romdhan, a mother of three in outer Tunis. "If [he] had stayed in the country it would be better.''
Kamel Fdela, selling oranges and bananas in the neighborhood, said he wants democracy but was not sure that would happen. He also feared food shortages, with so many stores closed and others looted.
"God willing, a real man will take over,'' he said.
Tunisian airspace reopened Saturday, but some flights were canceled and others left with delays. Thousands of tourists were still being evacuated from the Mediterranean nation known for its sandy beaches, desert landscapes and ancient ruins. Tour operator Thomas Cook's German subsidiary sent home 200 tourists from Tunisia on Friday, but 1,800 were still waiting to be flown out.
President Barack Obama said he applauded the courage and dignity of protesting Tunisians, and urged all parties to keep calm and avoid violence.
Saudi King Abdullah's palace confirmed Saturday that the ousted president and some family members had landed in Saudi Arabia, saying the kingdom welcomed him with a wish for "peace and security to return to the people of Tunisia.''
It did not give Ben Ali's exact whereabouts, but a source inside the kingdom said he was in the small city of Abha, about 310 miles south of Jeddah. The source said Ben Ali had been taken there to avoid sparking any possible demonstrations by Tunisians living in the larger, seaside city of Jeddah. He spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter.
The French government, meanwhile, said other members of Ben Ali's family were "not welcome'' in the former colonial ruler. Spokesman Francois Baroin told France-Info radio that Ben Ali's family "have not shown a desire to stay on French soil and are going to leave.''
He didn't specify which family members are currently in France.
Ben Ali's downfall sent a warning to other autocratic leaders across the Arab world, especially because he did not seem especially vulnerable until very recently and managed his country of 10 million better than many other Middle Eastern nations.
He turned Tunisia into a beach haven for European tourists, helping create an area of stability in volatile North Africa. There was a lack of civil rights and little or no freedom of speech, but a better quality of life for many than in neighboring countries such as Algeria and Libya.
Ben Ali won frequent praise from abroad for presiding over reforms to make the economy more competitive and attract business. Growth last year was at 3.1 percent.
Unemployment, however, was officially 14 percent but believed to be far higher among the young. Despair among job-seeking young graduates was palpable.
The riots started after an educated but jobless 26-year-old committed suicide in mid-December when police confiscated the fruits and vegetables he was selling without a permit. His desperate act hit a nerve, sparked copycat suicides and focused generalized anger against the regime into a widespread revolt.
Arabs across the region celebrated news of the Tunisian uprising on Twitter, Facebook and blogs. Thousands of tweets congratulating the Tunisian people flooded the Internet, and many people changed their profile pictures to Tunisian flags.
Egyptian activists opposed to President Hosni Mubarak's three-decade regime looked to the events in Tunisia with hope. About 50 gathered outside the Tunisian Embassy in Cairo to celebrate, chanting "Ben Ali, tell Mubarak a plane is waiting for him, too!''
Ben Ali, 74, came to power in a bloodless palace coup in 1987. He took over from a man formally called President-for-Life Bourguiba, the founder of modern-day Tunisia who set the Muslim country on a pro-Western course after independence from France in 1956.
Ben Ali consistently won elections with questionable tallies: In 2009, he was re-elected for a fifth five-year term with 89 percent of the vote.
U.S. diplomatic cables recently released by WikiLeaks called Tunisia a "police state'' and described the widespread corruption there, saying Ben Ali had lost touch with his people. Social networks like Facebook helped spread the comments to the delight of ordinary Tunisians, who had complained about the same issues for years.
Enlarge Fethi Belaid/AFP/Getty Images A Tunisian woman waves the national flag in front of the Interior Ministry during clashes Friday between demonstrators and security forces in Tunis.
Fethi Belaid/AFP/Getty Images
A Tunisian woman waves the national flag in front of the Interior Ministry during clashes Friday between demonstrators and security forces in Tunis.
by The Associated Press
Source: NPR
Credit: Alyson Hurt
Credit: Alyson Hurt
Amid the political instability, looters emptied shops and torched the capital's main train station, and soldiers traded fire with assailants in front of the Interior Ministry in Tunis. At least 42 people were killed Saturday in a prison fire in a resort town and the director of another prison let 1,000 inmates flee after a deadly rebellion.
The interim president — Fouad Mebazaa, the former president of the lower house of parliament — ordered the creation of a unity government that could include the opposition, which had been frozen out and ignored under President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali's 23 years of autocratic rule.
Ben Ali abruptly fled the country Friday for Saudi Arabia following a month of street protests over corruption, a lack of jobs and clampdowns on civil liberties. Yet while the protests were mostly peaceful, the first day after his departure was chaotic — deadly.
The leadership changes came at a dizzying speed. After Ben Ali left, his longtime ally, Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi, stepped in briefly with a vague assumption of power that left open the possibility that Ben Ali could return. But on Saturday, Constitutional Council President Fethi Abdennadher declared the president's departure permanent and gave lawmaker Mebazaa 60 days in which to organize new elections.
Hours later, Mebazaa was sworn in.
Online Reports Detail Chaos, Deaths In Tunisia; Add Yours
As protests spread in Tunisia, we’re collecting social media from there. You can help us curate it.The move was one of reconciliation, but it was not clear how far the 77-year-old Mebazaa, who has been part of Tunisia's ruling class for decades, would go to invite the opposition into the government.
It was also unclear who would emerge as the top political leaders in a post-Ben Ali Tunisia: The autocratic leader has utterly dominated politics for decades, placing his allies in power and sending opponents to jail or into exile.
On the streets, the unrest was frightening.
A fire at a prison in the Mediterranean coastal resort of Monastir killed 42 people, coroner Tarek Mghirbi told The Associated Press on Saturday. The cause of the fire was not immediately clear.
In Mahdia, farther down the coast, there was a rebellion inside a prison holding an estimated 1,000 prisoners, with inmates setting fire to their mattresses. Soldiers opened fire and five inmates were killed, a top local official said. The director of the prison let the inmates flee to avoid further bloodshed, the official said, asking not to be identified because of security concerns.
Security forces and unidentified assailants had a shootout Saturday in front of the Interior Ministry that left two bodies on the ground. It was not clear whether they were dead or who they are.
Sporadic gunfire echoed around in the capital on Saturday. Black smoke billowed over a giant supermarket as looters torched and emptied it. An Associated Press photographer saw soldiers fire warning shots and try to stop looters from sacking the supermarket in Ariana, north of the capital, to no avail. Shops near the main bazaar were also looted.
Public television station TV7 broadcast phone calls from residents of working-class neighborhoods on the capital's outskirts, describing attacks against their homes by knife-wielding assailants.
"This isn't good at all. I'm very afraid for the kids and myself,'' said Lilia Ben Romdhan, a mother of three in outer Tunis. "If [he] had stayed in the country it would be better.''
Kamel Fdela, selling oranges and bananas in the neighborhood, said he wants democracy but was not sure that would happen. He also feared food shortages, with so many stores closed and others looted.
"God willing, a real man will take over,'' he said.
Tunisian airspace reopened Saturday, but some flights were canceled and others left with delays. Thousands of tourists were still being evacuated from the Mediterranean nation known for its sandy beaches, desert landscapes and ancient ruins. Tour operator Thomas Cook's German subsidiary sent home 200 tourists from Tunisia on Friday, but 1,800 were still waiting to be flown out.
President Barack Obama said he applauded the courage and dignity of protesting Tunisians, and urged all parties to keep calm and avoid violence.
Saudi King Abdullah's palace confirmed Saturday that the ousted president and some family members had landed in Saudi Arabia, saying the kingdom welcomed him with a wish for "peace and security to return to the people of Tunisia.''
It did not give Ben Ali's exact whereabouts, but a source inside the kingdom said he was in the small city of Abha, about 310 miles south of Jeddah. The source said Ben Ali had been taken there to avoid sparking any possible demonstrations by Tunisians living in the larger, seaside city of Jeddah. He spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter.
The French government, meanwhile, said other members of Ben Ali's family were "not welcome'' in the former colonial ruler. Spokesman Francois Baroin told France-Info radio that Ben Ali's family "have not shown a desire to stay on French soil and are going to leave.''
He didn't specify which family members are currently in France.
Ben Ali's downfall sent a warning to other autocratic leaders across the Arab world, especially because he did not seem especially vulnerable until very recently and managed his country of 10 million better than many other Middle Eastern nations.
He turned Tunisia into a beach haven for European tourists, helping create an area of stability in volatile North Africa. There was a lack of civil rights and little or no freedom of speech, but a better quality of life for many than in neighboring countries such as Algeria and Libya.
Ben Ali won frequent praise from abroad for presiding over reforms to make the economy more competitive and attract business. Growth last year was at 3.1 percent.
Unemployment, however, was officially 14 percent but believed to be far higher among the young. Despair among job-seeking young graduates was palpable.
The riots started after an educated but jobless 26-year-old committed suicide in mid-December when police confiscated the fruits and vegetables he was selling without a permit. His desperate act hit a nerve, sparked copycat suicides and focused generalized anger against the regime into a widespread revolt.
Arabs across the region celebrated news of the Tunisian uprising on Twitter, Facebook and blogs. Thousands of tweets congratulating the Tunisian people flooded the Internet, and many people changed their profile pictures to Tunisian flags.
Egyptian activists opposed to President Hosni Mubarak's three-decade regime looked to the events in Tunisia with hope. About 50 gathered outside the Tunisian Embassy in Cairo to celebrate, chanting "Ben Ali, tell Mubarak a plane is waiting for him, too!''
Ben Ali, 74, came to power in a bloodless palace coup in 1987. He took over from a man formally called President-for-Life Bourguiba, the founder of modern-day Tunisia who set the Muslim country on a pro-Western course after independence from France in 1956.
Ben Ali consistently won elections with questionable tallies: In 2009, he was re-elected for a fifth five-year term with 89 percent of the vote.
U.S. diplomatic cables recently released by WikiLeaks called Tunisia a "police state'' and described the widespread corruption there, saying Ben Ali had lost touch with his people. Social networks like Facebook helped spread the comments to the delight of ordinary Tunisians, who had complained about the same issues for years.
Unrest Engulfs Tunisia; President Flees
The country swore in a new interim president as gunfire echoed through the capital.Africa
Tunisia's President Departs Amid National Turmoil
Zine El Abidine Ben Ali also dissolved his government as throngs of protesters took to the streets.Africa
Protests Escalate In Tunisia As President Promises Changes
Eleanor Beardsley reports from the capital on violent protests in the North African nation.Related NPR Stories
Government Declares State Of Emergency In Tunisia Jan. 14, 2011
To Calm Unrest, Tunisia's President Promises Changes Jan. 14, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)