Last month, Mitt Romney's campaign got into a dustup with the
Washington Post after the newspaper
reported
that Bain Capital, the private equity firm the GOP presidential
candidate founded, invested in several US companies that outsourced jobs
to China and India. The campaign indignantly
demanded a retraction, claiming that these businesses did not send jobs overseas while Romney was running Bain, and the
Post
stood by its investigation. Yet there is another aspect to the
Romney-as-outsourcer controversy. According to government documents
reviewed by
Mother Jones, Romney, when he was in charge of
Bain, invested heavily in a Chinese manufacturing company that depended
on US outsourcing for its profits—and that explicitly stated that such
outsourcing was crucial to its success.
This previously unreported deal runs counter to Romney's tough talk
on the campaign trail regarding China. "We will not let China continue
to steal jobs from the United States of America," Romney
declared
in February. But with this investment, Romney sought to make money off a
foreign company that banked on American firms outsourcing manufacturing
overseas.
On April 17, 1998, Brookside Capital Partners Fund, a Bain Capital affiliate, filed a
report
with the Securities and Exchange Commission noting that it had acquired
6.13 percent of Hong Kong-based Global-Tech Appliances, which
manufactured household appliances in a production facility in the
industrial city of Dongguan, China. That August, according to
another SEC filing,
Brookside upped its interest in Global-Tech to 10.3 percent. Both SEC
filings identified Romney as the person in control of this investment:
"Mr. W. Mitt Romney is the sole shareholder, sole director, President
and Chief Executive Officer of Brookside Inc. and thus is the
controlling person of Brookside Inc." Each of these documents was signed
by Domenic Ferrante, a managing director of Brookside and Bain.
The
SEC filings do not reveal how much Romney initially invested in
Global-Tech (which is now known as Global-Tech Advanced Innovations).
But Brookside first acquired 748,000 shares at a time when Global-Tech
was mounting an IPO at
$19 a share. If that was the purchase price Brookside paid, then Romney's firm originally invested $14.2 million in the company.
At the time Romney was acquiring shares in Global-Tech, the firm
publicly acknowledged that its strategy was to profit from prominent US
companies outsourcing production abroad. On September 4, 1998,
Global-Tech issued
a press release
announcing it was postponing completion of a $30 million expansion of
its Dongguan facility because Sunbeam, a prominent American consumer
products company and a major client of Global-Tech, was cutting back on
outsourcing as part of an overall consolidation. But John C.K. Sham,
Global-Tech's president and CEO, said, "Although it appears that
customers such as Sunbeam are not outsourcing their manufacturing as
quickly as we had anticipated, we still believe that the long-term trend
toward outsourcing will continue." Global-Tech, which in mid-1998
announced fiscal year sales of $118.3 million (an increase of 89 percent
over the previous year), also manufactured household appliances for
Hamilton Beach, Mr. Coffee, Proctor-Silex, Revlon, and Vidal Sassoon,
and its chief exec was hoping for more outsourcing from these and other
American firms.
The Romney campaign and Bain Capital have insisted that Romney
departed Bain in February 1999 to head the troubled 2002 Winter
Olympics in Salt Lake City and had no involvement in the private equity
firm's deals after that point—a contention that has been
challenged by the Obama campaign. But the Global-Tech Appliances transactions occurred long before Romney jetted off to Utah.
At the time Romney was acquiring shares in
Global-Tech, the firm publicly acknowledged that its strategy was to
profit from prominent US companies outsourcing production abroad.
Brookside downsized its Global-Tech holdings later in 1998.
An SEC filing
submitted on December 21, 1998, reported that the Bain affiliate now
controlled only 4.63 percent of the company's shares. But Brookside was
sharing its stake in Global-Tech with Sankaty High Yield Asset
Investors LTD—a Bermuda-based corporation of which Romney was the "the
sole shareholder, a director, and President." That is, Romney had split
his Global-Tech holdings between two of his various business entities.
(The SEC filing doesn't indicate why he did that.)
Sankaty is a story in itself. It was recently the focus of an Associated Press investigation that
reported
that Sankaty "is among several Romney holdings that have not been
fully disclosed" and that there is a "mystery surrounding" Sankaty.
Reporting on this Romney entity,
Vanity Fair noted
that "investments in tax havens such as Bermuda raise many questions,
because they are in 'jurisdictions where there is virtually no tax and
virtually no compliance,' as one Miami-based offshore lawyer put it."
With Sankaty, Romney was using a mysterious Bermuda-based entity to
invest in a Chinese firm that thrived on US outsourcing.
In early 1999, Romney's investment in Global-Tech expanded again.
An SEC report
filed on March 25, 1999, stated that Brookside and Sankaty at this
stage owned 9.11 percent of the firm's stock. Romney was still listed
as the sole shareholder and president of both Brookside and Sankaty.
By this point, according to the open-to-question account offered by
Bain and the Romney campaign, Romney no longer had any involvement in
Bain deals. But the series of SEC filings show active Brookside and
Sankaty trading in Global-Tech Appliances while Romney fully controlled
these firms. The two Romney companies repeatedly changed their
ownership stake in this Chinese firm, which was not shy about its
dependence on outsourcing. In its
2001 annual report,
Global-Tech noted that US outsourcing was essential to its prospects:
"Household appliance companies are focusing on their primary strengths
of marketing and distribution, while increasingly outsourcing product
development and manufacturing…Our ability and commitment to develop new
and innovative, high quality products at a low cost has allowed us to
benefit from the increased outsourcing of product development and
manufacturing by our customers."
In August 2000, Brookside and Sankaty sold their interest in Global-Tech, according to
the SEC documents.
With these filings disclosing minimum details about Romney's
investment in Global-Tech, there is no telling how much money he
made—or lost—on the deal.
A spokeswoman for Bain says that the company will not comment on the
Global-Tech investment or provide any additional details about this
deal. A Romney campaign official would not address the issue of
Global-Tech profiting from US outsourcing, but this Romney aide
maintains that this deal was nothing other than a routine investment in a
foreign company: "[I]t's my understanding that while Brookside is a
part of Bain Capital, it is not a private equity vehicle. Brookside
makes passive investments in public stock. They don't control or manage
the companies they invest in. Brookside had a small ownership stake
(9.11%) in Global-Tech…while Romney was there. If owning shares in a
foreign company is somehow wrong, President Obama is guilty as well."
(The Romney campaign points out that Obama's personal holdings include
an investment in a Vanguard 500 Index retirement fund that contains
shares in a handful of foreign companies.)
In recent weeks, Romney's involvement in outsourcing has become a
contentious campaign issue. Late last month, the Obama campaign launched
ads that accused Romney of being a "corporate raider" who "shipped
jobs to China and Mexico" and slammed him as an "outsourcer in chief."
The Romneyites cried foul, pointing to neutral fact-checkers who
criticized the ads, and asserted that Obama was trying to distract from
bad economic news. And the Romney campaign, pushing back on the
Post story,
maintained
that the newspaper missed the difference between outsourcing and
offshoring. This week, Romney declared that Obama was the real
"outsourcer-in-chief," insisting that the president funded "energy
companies, solar and wind energy companies that end up making their
products outside the United States." (The
New York Times immediately
debunked much of Romney's attack, and the
Washington Post's "Fact Checker" column awarded
four Pinocchios to an Americans for Prosperity ad that in April made a similar claim about Obama and green-jobs outsourcing.)
Romney's Global-Tech deal adds a new dimension to the debate over
Romney and outsourcing. Whether or not he was at the helm when Bain
invested in US firms that did or did not ship jobs overseas, Romney was
in command when a company he owned and controlled bought a large stake
in a Chinese venture that counted on American companies sending
manufacturing—and that means jobs—to China. These days, Romney rails
against China for swiping American jobs and proclaims, "For me, it's
all about good jobs for the American people." But when there was money
to be made by acquiring a chunk of a Chinese company that aimed to
displace American manufacturers (and American workers), Romney's
patriotism did not interfere with the potential for profit.
Research assistance: James Carter