Americans for Prosperity has been active on the airwaves
already this election cycle. The group, which opposes Obamacare, has run
a handful of ads featuring people telling health care "horror stories"
meant to tug on the heartstrings. We’ve looked at
a couple and
explained how they can be misleading.
But a pair of new ads take an entirely different tack to undercut
support from Democratic Sens. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana and Mark Udall
of Colorado.
In these ads, a woman on screen trashes political ads in her 30-second personal pitch.
"People don’t like political ads. I don’t like them either. But
health care isn’t about politics," she says. "It’s about people. And
millions of people have lost their health insurance, millions of people
can’t see their own doctors, and millions are paying more and getting
less."
We’ve tackled claims about
lost insurance and
access to personal doctors before. But we haven’t heard someone say that the health care law
is causing people to pay more for less
, so we decided to check it out.
Paying more
There are a lot of factors in the health care law — and health
insurance in general — that make it difficult to pin down whether people
are paying more or less for coverage.
In general, insurance premiums were increasing every year well before
Obamacare became law. In fact, rates have increased consistently during
the last 15 years. But there are signs that the rate of the increase
has declined since the law was passed.
Kaiser Family Foundation, for example, surveyed people who purchase insurance through their employer. Here are the average annual cost of premiums:
| Year |
Single |
% increase |
Family |
% increase |
| 1999 |
$2,196 |
|
$5,791 |
|
| 2000 |
$2,471 |
12.52% |
$6,438 |
11.17% |
| 2001 |
$2,689 |
8.82% |
$7,061 |
9.68% |
| 2002 |
$3,083 |
14.65% |
$8,003 |
13.34% |
| 2003 |
$3,383 |
9.73% |
$9,068 |
13.31% |
| 2004 |
$3,695 |
9.22% |
$9,950 |
9.73% |
| 2005 |
$4,024 |
8.90% |
$10,880 |
9.35% |
| 2006 |
$4,242 |
5.42% |
$11,480 |
5.51% |
| 2007 |
$4,479 |
5.59% |
$12,106 |
5.45% |
| 2008 |
$4,704 |
5.02% |
$12,680 |
4.74% |
| 2009 |
$4,824 |
2.55% |
$13,375 |
5.48% |
| 2010 |
$5,049 |
4.66% |
$13,770 |
2.95% |
| 2011 |
$5,429 |
7.53% |
$15,073 |
9.46% |
| 2012 |
$5,615 |
3.43% |
$15,745 |
4.46% |
| 2013 |
$5,884 |
4.79% |
$16,351 |
3.85% |
Other than a sharp increase between 2010 to 2011, the Obama years
have experienced the smallest rate increases of the last 14 years.
Throughout much of the early 2000s, premium increases of 9 percent or
more were the norm.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid also found a slowdown in the
increase in health costs during the last four years, including a modest 4
percent increase from 2011 to 2012.
The government attributed the decrease in health costs to the economic downturn.
Kaiser, too, said the recession accounted for much of the decline, though they said the health care law may have played a role, too.
Because of the law, people making up to 400 percent of the federal
poverty level are now eligible for subsidies to buy insurance, and for
many of them, costs are going down.
Those costs are capped at a percent of their income.
But some people may see rate increases on existing policies or as they transition to new plans.
Insurers can no longer deny individuals with pre-existing conditions,
and there is now a much larger pool of people looking to purchase
coverage. For younger, healthier people, this means they are now taking
on some of the financial burden so older or sick people can buy
insurance at a reasonable price. (This is especially true for young
males, since young women were often charged more, and even more so if
they don’t qualify for premium subsidies.)
There were also people who previously purchased very cheap plans. But
those policies provided very little coverage or capped their benefits
at low levels, which the new health care law bars. So they’re getting
more coverage, albeit at a greater cost.
Getting less?
Which gets us to our next point.
We found it strange that the ad claimed that people are getting less
under the Affordable Care Act. In fact, we’ve usually heard the opposite
from critics of the law that people are now paying for types of
coverage they don’t need.
The favorite example is single men who now will now have maternity
coverage if they buy a plan on the individual market. In October 2013,
Rep. Renee Ellmers, R-N.C., grilled Secretary of Health and Human
Services Kathleen Sebelius on this very point.
"An insurance policy has a series of benefits whether you use them or not," Sebelius said during her testimony on the Hill.
"And that is why the health care premiums are increasing this high,"
Ellmers said. "We’re forcing them to buy things that they will never
need."
"Individual policies cover families. Men often do need maternity
coverage for their spouses and for their families," Sebelius responded.
"To the best of your knowledge, has a man ever delivered a baby?" Elmers asked. The discussion ended there.
So are you getting less coverage, or getting more than you need? We asked Americans for Prosperity to clarify their position.
"Getting less speaks to a multitude of data points that has been
America's Obamacare experience so far: botched website, shrinking
provider networks, a string of broken promises, missed deadlines, and
unilateral rule changes that have kept the entire country in limbo ever
since this debacle rolled out," said spokesman Levi Russell.
That’s a pretty ambiguous definition of "less." We think most people
would assume "less" is referring to the amount of coverage or benefits
under the law.
Americans are getting more benefits under the law in a number of ways
-- including, in some cases, being able to buy affordable insurance for
the first time.
In addition, insurance purchased in the individual and small group
marketplace must meet 10 essential health benefits. This includes
coverage for emergency services and hospitalization, prescription drugs,
free preventative coverage for things ranging from basic immunizations
to HIV screening, and maternity care.
The law also caps out-of-pocket costs, providing greater protection
from exorbitant hospital bills. The most a person could pay for health
care in a year is $6,300; the most a family can pay is $12,600.
Before the law passed, some insurers capped annual or lifetime
benefits, forcing people who thought they were covered to pay large
hospital bills once they passed the threshold.
People with pre-existing conditions are also seeing a lot more benefits, since they previously couldn’t buy a policy at all.
So it’s a tough sell to say millions are getting less. And for many, they aren’t paying more, either.
Our ruling
Americans for Prosperity said "millions are paying more and getting
less" under Obamacare. We found their explanation of "less" rather
dubious. Most people on the individual market are getting more benefits
under the law. At worst, they’re paying more to get more, though in many
cases they’re actually paying less.
We rate this claim False.
Thursday, March 20th, 2014 at 4:12 p.m.
Email interview with Levi Russell, spokesman for Americans for Prosperity, March 19, 2014
," Feb. 6, 2013
, Aug. 20, 2013
, Sept. 19, 2013
," Dec. 2013
, Nov. 2013
," Oct. 30, 2013
," Aug. 29, 2013