NORTON META TAG

Showing posts with label Statue of Liberty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Statue of Liberty. Show all posts

20 March 2025

White House says U.S. won’t return Statue of Liberty to France 18MAR25



karoline leavitt really is an idiot. Not only do we owe the French our friendship and gratitude for helping us win our independence. It is because thousands of French soldiers sacrificed themselves holding back the German army while the British forces and a lot of French forces were evacuated from Dunkirk. Lighten up on the peroxide karolynn, it's eating into your brain.

White House says U.S. won’t return Statue of Liberty to France

The Statue of Liberty in October. (Charly Triballeau/AFP/Getty Images)

The White House has dismissed a French politician’s symbolic call for the return of the Statue of Liberty — a gift from France some 140 years ago — on the grounds that the United States no longer represents the values embodied by the monument.

President Donald Trump would “absolutely not” return the statue, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said Monday when asked about the comments from Raphaël Glucksmann, a member of the European Parliament.

“My advice to that unnamed low-level French politician would be to remind them that it’s only because of the United States of America that the French are not speaking German right now,” Leavitt said, referring to the U.S. role in helping France during World War II. “So they should be very grateful to our great country.”

The United States played a major role in freeing France from four years of occupation by Nazi Germany, but it did not act alone. On June 6, 1944, Allied forces — primarily American, British and Canadian troops — launched the pivotal D-Day invasion, which marked the beginning of France’s liberation.

Glucksmann, from France’s center-left Place Publique party, made the quip about the Statue of Liberty during a party convention Sunday.

“We are going to tell the Americans — those who have chosen to side with tyrants, those who fire researchers for exercising scientific freedom — we are going to tell them two things. First of all, give us back the Statue of Liberty!” he said.

“We gave it to you as a gift, but apparently, you despise it. So let it be here with us,” he added.

Glucksmann, a vocal advocate for Ukraine’s defense in its war against Russia, has previously accused European leaders of not providing sufficient support to Kyiv.

In his comments Sunday, he was also critical of the Trump administration’s gutting of federal assistance to U.S. research institutes. Earlier this month, France’s minister for higher education and research urged institutions in the country to welcome researchers affected by Trump’s cuts in the United States.

Julian Jackson, an emeritus professor of modern French history at Queen Mary University of London, called Glucksmann a respected and articulate leader. “And the Statue of Liberty is of course a reminder that America partly owes her independence to the French, as in the War of Independence,” he said in an email.

France provided arms, ammunition, troops and naval support to the American colonies during the Revolutionary War.

The Statue of Liberty, a prominent symbol of freedom and hope, draws millions of visitors every year. It was first imagined by Édouard de Laboulaye of France, an ardent admirer of the United States, as a gift to commemorate the centennial of the Declaration of Independence and the abolition of slavery.

Sculptor Frédéric-Auguste Bartholdi designed the statue to capture those values: a crown representing light, an inscription noting the date of American independence and a broken shackle and chains to mark the end of slavery. The completed statue was disassembled and shipped to New York in 1885, while the plaque with the famous Emma Lazarus poem was added in 1903.

In a social media thread late Monday, Glucksmann responded to Leavitt by acknowledging the heroism of the “hundreds of thousands of young Americans” who landed on the beaches of Normandy while casting the Trump administration’s stance on Ukraine as a betrayal of the war-battered country and the United States’ European allies.

Europe has been alarmed by Trump’s embrace of Russian President Vladimir Putin and struggled to adapt to Washington’s wavering support for Ukraine. Trump and Putin will speak by phone Tuesday to discuss ending the war in Ukraine, according to the Kremlin.

“No one, of course, will come and steal the Statue of Liberty. The statue is yours. But what it embodies belongs to everyone,” Glucksmann wrote. “And if the free world no longer interests your government, then we will take up the torch, here in Europe.”


Sabrina Rodriguez contributed to this report.


Trump presidency

Follow live updates on the Trump administration. We’re tracking President Donald Trump’s actions by dayhis progress on campaign promises, and legal challenges to his executive orders and actions.

The economy: Concerns are heightening that the U.S. economy is heading toward a recession as the stock market slides amid the Trump administration’s implementation of tariffs. Here’s how to prepare and what to do with your 401(k).

Federal workers: The Trump administration continues to work to downsize the federal government — eliminating thousands of jobs at agencies, including: USAIDthe IRS, the Social Security Administrationthe Education Departmentthe Defense Departmenthealth agencies, the National Weather Service and the National Park Service.

U.S. DOGE Service: Elon Musk and his team have moved to dismantle some U.S. agenciespush out hundreds of thousands of civil servants and gain access to some of the federal government’s most sensitive payment systems. Here’s who’s working for DOGE.

Trump’s advisers: Several of Trump’s Cabinet picks, including Robert F. Kennedy Jr.Tulsi GabbardMarco Rubio and Pete Hegseth have been confirmedWe’re tracking nominations here.



03 August 2017

It turns out Stephen Miller's immigrant great-grandmother couldn't speak English & Trump aide uses White House podium to echo white supremacist claims about Statue of Liberty & Trump aide goes off rails, cites hate groups, disses Lady Liberty's 'Give me your tired' call 3&2AUG17

Related image
MORE hypocrisy, more racist rhetoric and propaganda from the drumpf/trump-pence administration, this time on immigration. Seems NOT MY pres drumpf's/trump's grandfather came to America unable to speak English (and he was a draft dodger too), and the same is true for stephen miller's great-grandmother, kellyanne conway's great-grandfather, and research is ongoing on steve bannon's great-great grandfather from Bavaria. These people would have been barred from entering the U.S. under the drumpf/trump-pence administration's immigration policy! 
It turns out Stephen Miller's immigrant great-grandmother  couldn't speak English
Thursday Aug 03, 2017

Stephen Miller is a strange man. A strange, racist man. A strange, racist, gives-you-the-heebie-jeebies man. On Wednesday, after Donald Trump announced his anti-immigrant immigration idea, Miller was sent out to talk with the press corps, because there are few people who can freak everybody out as much as Stephen Miller can. After parroting white supremacist talking points on immigrants not being able to speak English and the Statue of Liberty being a propaganda campaign by who-knows-who (probably Bolsheviks!), thinking folk decided to figure out how large a hypocrite Mr. Miller was. It didn’t take long.
As someone in Twitter thread pointed out, this makes Miller similar, in one respect, to humanity.
And as the Washington Post points out, the only good advertisement for this racist and scapegoating immigration policy is that it may have spared us from our current leadership.
A biographer of Trumpf — father of Fred Trump, who was the father of the president — told Deutsche Welle that Donald Trump’s grandfather didn’t speak English when he got here.
[...]
Reporter Jennifer Mendelsohn tracked down Miller’s genealogy. She discovered that Miller’s father’s father’s mother — his great-grandmother, Sarah Miller — was identified in the 1910 Census as speaking only Yiddish.
[...]
Kellyanne Conway’s great-grandfather was named Pasquale Lombardo and was born in Naples, Italy. A man of that name and the proper age is identified in the 1910 Census as living in Pennsylvania and working as a blast furnace laborer who spoke only Italian.
Stephen K. Bannon’s great-great-grandfather was a man named Mattias Herr, who was born in Bavaria in 1836 before moving to Maryland. It’s not clear whether he spoke English or knew a skilled trade.
Maybe they will retroactively deport themselves?
Thursday Aug 03, 2017
Is White House senior policy adviser Stephen Miller a white nationalist? It’s a question worth asking after he stood at the White House podium on Wednesday and echoed a white nationalist argument about the Statue of Liberty. As Miller detailed Donald Trump’s plan to limit legal immigration, he was asked about the poem on the Statue of Liberty. You know the one—“Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” Miller’s response was that the poem was “added later,” so it’s irrelevant to American values. That sounds like a nonsensical answer, until you see all of the straight-up white supremacists who’ve made that exact argument before Miller. Rebekah Entralgo rounds up some of them:
Stormfront.org, a popular website among white supremacists that boasts the tagline, “Every month is White history month,” has a numerous discussion threads on the topic, including one titled, “Give Me Your Huddled Masses — The Jewess who tried to destroy the US!” Contributors to the forum wrote the poem should be “considered graffiti” and stress that [Emma] Lazarus’ sonnet is “not part of the original” statue at all.
The subreddit for Donald Trump supporters, which frequently pushes white nationalist memes, also has a post titled, “Does everyone realize that the poem inscribed beneath the Statue of Liberty is not, in fact, law?”
So basically they want the Statue of Liberty to be their Aryan imaginary girlfriend and not associated with nasty Jews and other non-Aryan immigrants. David Duke has even written a book chapter complaining about Emma Lazarus. And these are the people whose argument a senior White House aide parroted on Wednesday.
Mind you, the fact that the poem was added later shows exactly how important it is. The easy thing to do was leave it off. It took work and money and political will to add it, and that happened because those words added something meaningful to the statue. But if you’re a white supremacist desperately looking to disavow the values embedded in that statue for more than a century now, along with the “Jewess” who wrote them, “it was added later” will do, I guess.

The White House on Wednesday put forward the architect of Donald Trump's most racist, anti-immigrant policies to put a public face on the administration's new all-systems-go nativist push and it was, well, jaw dropping.
Stephen Miller, a former Jeff Sessions staffer, embodied all the pompousness of a former Hill staffer who read a few studies and decided he knew everything about immigration policy—a topic that has flummoxed Congress and presidents alike for several decades. Which studies, you ask? Ones that have either been debunked, like George Borjas's study of what Cuban immigration did to Miami's economy, or ones authored by the SPLC-designated hate group the Center for Immigration Studies.
Under pressure, Miller touted both as a rationale for Trump's support of a new bill sponsored by GOP Sens. Tom Cotton and David Perdue that aims to limit legal immigration into the U.S.
Miller packed a lot of bluster and blasphemy into about 30 minutes at the White House podium, but here's the bottom line: His appearance laid bare the fact that the Trump administration is focusing on immigration as an electoral strategy to divide and conquer.
Miller repeatedly mentioned how "blue collar" workers had suffered at the hands of unskilled immigrant workers who had displaced them. But he made sure to make the appeal about all working-class Americans who, according to his studies, have been dealt a raw deal by immigration.
So you've seen over time as a result of this historic flow of unskilled immigration, a shift in wealth from the working class to wealthier corporations and businesses, and it's been very unfair for American workers, but especially for immigrant workers, African-American workers and Hispanic workers and blue collar workers in general across the country.
What a perfect catchall—if you're black, white, Hispanic, whatever, and identify as “blue collar” or “working class,” you should be mad because you've been dealt a raw deal by immigrants who have taken your jobs and pushed down your wages—according to his studies.
Asked if the administration had any chance of getting this legislation through Congress given an already behind-the-eight-ball packed calendar dedicated to the debt ceiling, the 2018 budget, tax reform, infrastructure, and maybe taking another whack at healthcare repeal, Miller had no answer.
Ultimately we're going to have to have conversations with Senate leadership and House leadership about the steps forward, but this is an issue that we campaigned on, the American people voted for... [blah blah blah]
Translation: No, there's no chance. But it's a great campaign issue.
Miller also went on attack against any reporters in the room searching for real answers. He cited the bogus studies in response to repeated questioning from Glenn Thrush and then he got flummoxed, offering up this gem:
Maybe it's time we have compassion, Glenn, for American workers.
He also dissed the inscription on the Statue of Liberty that reads"Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free."
There was more, much more. But Trump needs a pound of flesh now that he’s a legislative loser and this is where they are turning.