NORTON META TAG

Showing posts with label Bella Santorum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bella Santorum. Show all posts

10 March 2012

Santorum in '93: More Government Needed in Health Care & Santorum Concedes That His Private Health Insurance Sucks 5MAR12

HERE is another example of Christian rick santorum lying to the electorate about his positions on government involvement in health care. If he has changed his positions on the issue he should just say so, but to lie about it and mislead and manipulate the voters is wrong, and is another reason to reject him as a candidate for president. Here are two articles from Mother Jones, one about his earlier positions on government and health care and the second about his private health insurance......

EXCLUSIVE: The 2012 candidate once argued it was wrong for the federal government not to be "proactive" in shaping the health care market and boasted his voting record was "in the middle."



rick santorum2012 Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum.
Rick Santorum's pitch to Republican voters is simple: He is the "true" and "consistent" conservative in the GOP's presidential nomination fight. He describes himself as "a candidate who, throughout [his] career, has not only checked the box on conservative issues but has fought for conservative issues." And he slams front-runner Mitt Romney for flip-flopping on abortion and the Wall Street bailouts and, most of all, for passing government-mandated health care reform in Massachusetts. If elected president, Santorum vows, he will end the "tyranny" of President Obama's Affordable Care Act.
Yet as an up-and-coming congressman in the early 1990s, Santorum took a much different line. Then—like now—health care was one of the nation's most divisive issues. In 1993, Republicans were up in arms about a health care reform bill spearheaded by Hillary Clinton and pushed by President Bill Clinton. Republicans decried the measure as excessive government intervention in the marketplace, and Santorum opposed the legislation. But his position was not so clear-cut.
During that fiery debate, Santorum said it would be a mistake to allow the delivery of health care services to be determined only by the market. He asserted that Republicans were "wrong" to let the marketplace decide how health care works. He instead argued that government should play a "proactive" role in shaping the health care marketplace "to make it work better." (Santorum spokesman Hogan Gidley did not respond to requests for comment.)
Santorum's call for more government intervention in health care came during a December 1993 appearance on a Pittsburgh TV program, The Editors, hosted by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's Jane Blotzer and John Craig. At the time, Santorum was running in a Republican Senate primary and looking to challenge Democratic incumbent Sen. Harris Wofford. Mother Jones obtained a previously unreported transcript of the interview made by staffers for the Wofford reelection campaign. In 1994 Santorum eked out a narrow win over Wofford, 49 percent to 47 percent, in a bitterly fought race that gained national attention.
In the 1993 interview, the 35-year-old Santorum sounds little like the unflinching conservative he claims to be today. He describes his voting record in the US House of Representatives, where he represented the eastern suburbs of Pittsburgh, as "pretty much in the middle" compared with the rest of the Pennsylvania delegation, which included 11 Democrats and 9 other Republicans. His record, he went on, was "pretty compatible" with that of Arlen Specter and the late John Heinz, both moderate Republican senators from Pennsylvania. (Specter later switched to the Democratic Party.)
In the interview, when asked about the role of government in Americans' lives, Santorum responded, "I believe that the federal government should set up a system where we create the right incentives for you to make efficient choices."
Santorum said of health care in 1993: "A lot of folks believe, 'Well, just keep government out of it.' I don't believe that."
On health care, as he called for more government involvement, Santorum said Republicans had "dropped the ball" by not making health care reform a headline issue in recent elections. "I even said it to President Bush when he came to Pittsburgh to campaign for Dick Thornburgh [then running for US Senate] in 1991, that health care was gonna be the big issue and that we had to take responsibility for trying to solve this problem," Santorum said. "We can't continue to ignore it and say, 'Oh well, you know, it will work itself out in the marketplace.' That's wrong."
Government intervention, he continued, was key to creating a functioning health care marketplace. "The government helps set the marketplace up, so we have some responsibility to alter that marketplace to make it work better."
Talking about health care, Santorum explained: "I take a much more proactive position in government in solving problems than most Republicans, because I believe government has a role. A lot of folks believe, 'Well, just keep government out of it.' I don't believe that." He added, "I think government has a role in making sure that there is equal opportunity."
On the campaign trail these days, Santorum denounces government and maintains that it is not government's job to help those who are suffering (because suffering has its positive consequences, he contends). His top priority, he says, is repealing "Obamacare." He also wants to privatize Medicare and eliminate the agency that oversees it. "You want the private sector out there competing, driving down costs, improving efficiency," he said recently.
At a November 2011 debate, Santorum boasted about his unwavering conservative record on health care. "I was always for having the government out of the health care business," he said, "and for a bottom-up, consumer-driven health care, which is different than Governor Romney and some of the other people on this panel." Yet Santorum, who has attacked Romney for reversing his positions, has flip-flopped as well.

02 March 2012

Rick Santorum: Obamacare Poster Boy 1MAR12 & Rick Santorum calls for low-income children to suffer 21NOV11

rick santorum's position on suffering as being part of life is cruel, evil and un-Christian. He said "Suffering, if you're a Christian, suffering is a part of life. And it's not a bad thing, it is an essential thing in life." There is no Biblical basis for his statement, it is a perversion of the true teachings of Jesus Christ. Matthew 5:3-12, the Sermon on the Mount, addresses suffering due to grief (v.4) and persecution because of their faith (v. 10-12). John 15:18 through 16:4 addresses suffering by believers because of their faith as does Romans 8:18-30 and 1 Peter 4:12-19. 2 Corinthians 4:1-15 is a lesson on suffering and holding on to faith but does not condone it as a good life experience. Nowhere in Scripture are Christians told to tolerate the suffering of others, to do nothing to alleviate the suffering of others or to prevent actions by anyone to prevent the suffering of others. rick santorum's Christianity lacks compassion and mercy, basic tenants of our faith. If he wants to believe suffering is a good thing in his life that is his decision, he should not cause suffering for others. And rick, you may want to read the Scripture mentioned above to see what is in store for those causing the suffering of others.......This from Mother Jones & Daily Kos.......

The candidate's tax returns reveal staggering medical bills that would bankrupt many Americans—yet Santorum wants to roll back programs that would help families like his.

2012 Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum
During a recent interview with Glenn Beck, Rick and Karen Santorum suggested that the Obama administration's health care reform law would harm people with disabilities, like their three-year-old daughter, Bella, who suffers from a rare and usually fatal genetic disorder. In fact, it was because of President Obama's health care overhaul, they said, that the former Pennsylvania senator decided to seek the presidency. "We have as you know a little angel, little Bella, special-needs little girl, and when Obamacare passed, that was it, that put the fire in my belly," Karen said. Rick added that Obama's Affordable Care Act is "all about the usefulness of the person to society, instead of the dignity of every human life and the opportunity for people who love and care for people to give them the best possibility to have the best possible life." Yet, even as the Santorums bash Obamacare, their own family story—which includes staggering medical bills that would bankrupt many American families—makes the case for the health care policies that they vigorously oppose.
By cashing in on his senatorial connections to join the 1 percent, Santorum managed to escape the crippling debt that can come with raising a disabled child. But his tax returns appear to show how expensive caring for a disabled child can be under the current health care system, even for someone with health insurance. In 2009 and 2010, the Santorums racked up $100,000 in medical expenses—more than the median American family income each year—and that's after their private insurance paid some costs. During that same time period, they also had nearly $100,000 worth of household assistance—help they didn't have in 2007, before Bella was born. (The Santorum campaign did not respond to questions from Mother Jones about the exact nature of these expenses.)
"The financial implications [of having a disabled child] can be pretty catastrophic pretty fast," says Katy Neas, senior vice president for government affairs at Easter Seals, which provides services to more than a million disabled people every year. "Families end up losing everything because of health care costs." She says the medical expenses the Santorums have incurred aren't unusual for families with disabled children. Private insurance plans, she says, don't meet these kids' needs, largely because they impose tight limits on payments for the various therapies disabled kids require. And until the Obama health care reform law passed, insurers simply wouldn't cover many disabled children.
Nebraska resident Lisa Gourley knows this well. Deprived of oxygen in the womb, her son Colin was born with serious brain damage. After his birth, Gourley couldn't go back to work because Colin needed round-the-clock attention and intensive medical care. The family had to rely on one income. And as Colin, now 18, got older, Gourley says that private insurance didn't cover everything he needed. For instance, one year his feet grew faster than expected, and he ended up requiring a second set of $3,000 leg braces. Insurance would only pay for one pair each year.
Not only has he had 14 orthopedic surgeries, but Colin needs physical therapy between three and five times a week to stay out of a wheelchair. Private insurance would only pay for enough therapy visits to get him through March or April, leaving the family scrambling to pay for the rest of his sessions. The mounting medical expenses nearly sent the family of six into bankruptcy, a fate they only avoided by selling their house and moving in with Gourley's in-laws for several years. Gourley's husband lost his banking job during the financial crisis, and with it, their private insurance. Later, after her husband found a new job, Gourley discovered that not a single company would insure Colin. "They barely insure you if you have high blood pressure, let alone brain damage," she says.
The new health care reform law now requires insurers to cover kids like Colin, but most of the provisions that will really make private insurance a viable option for families like the Gourleys won't kick in for a few more years. So he remains on Medicaid, the government health care program for low-income people that has seen severe cuts during the recession, making it difficult for the Gourleys to even find doctors and caretakers who will participate in the program because the reimbursements are now so low.
Despite Medicaid's crucial role in helping families with disabled kids, Santorum has promised that, if elected, he would further slash the program by 10 percent and then freeze the budget for four years. He has also proposed shifting the program's funding into block grants to the states, a move that would likely result in severe budget cuts. Easter Seals, not surprisingly, opposes both of these moves because of the impact it could have on disabled people.
Of course, many middle-class families of disabled children like the Gourleys might not need Medicaid if private health insurance coverage were sufficient—but as the Santorums' tax returns suggest, it isn't. The new health care reform law that Santorum has vowed to repeal if elected is designed to eventually remedy part of that problem.
It will put an end to annual or lifetime caps on benefits, which are easily hit by disabled kids. By 2014, the law's "essential benefits" package will require coverage for "habilitative" services, things like speech, occupational, or physical therapy, which are critical to the quality of life for special-needs children. And the law will increase payments to doctors who take Medicaid, which will help ensure that disabled kids in the program can actually find a good provider.
Beyond that, the Affordable Care Act expands the number of people who are eligible for Medicaid to include families making 133 percent of the federal poverty line, so that more disabled children will be covered. Santorum is deeply opposed to this sort of socialism. In November, he complained that people who weren't stuck in poverty could qualify for Medicaid, which he said would only lead to a sense of entitlement among children in the program. Better to let the people do without, he said: "Suffering, if you're a Christian, suffering is a part of life. And it's not a bad thing, it is an essential thing in life."
If Santorum were to win the White House, his health care policies would certainly impose some suffering upon many families with disabled children. And the negative impacts of those policies would be exacerbated if Santorum were able to implement his theologically driven opposition to abortion and birth control. A devout Catholic, Santorum has said that birth control is "harmful to women" and "harmful to our society"—because he thinks that sex should only be a procreative act among heterosexual married people. He thinks the Supreme Court was misguided when it struck down a ban on the sale of contraception to married people in 1965. Presumably, he and Karen have eschewed contraception—and at the age of 48, Karen had Bella.
Were Santorum to deny women, particularly those in their 40s, abortion and contraception, more families—including those of lesser means—would face the severe challenges of raising disabled children. The possibility for serious complications rises exponentially among older women should they forgo contraception. Humans weren't designed to have children well into mid-life. The risk of having a child with Down Syndrome for a woman in her 20s is 1 in 1,250. At age 45, the risk jumps to 1 in 30. At 49, it's 1 in 10. Most American women who conceive a disabled child choose to abort. Santorum is certainly free to find fault with this on moral grounds. But if disabled children are gifts from God, as Santorum has said, why make it harder for parents to care for them? More people, too, might forgo abortion if they could be sure that bearing a disabled child would not bankrupt them.
After Santorum mentioned Bella in a debate last fall, people on the campaign trail started asking questions about her. So he made a moving video to let the public have a glimpse of the child who is too medically fragile to join him on the stump. On many levels, the Santorums have a lot to teach us. But what's missing from their tale is any evidence that their own personal trials have given them insight into other people's suffering—or compassion for it. Supporting health care reform so disabled children can have a fighting chance at living with dignity can be just as moral as opposing abortion. Yet Santorum seems unable to recognize that the inspiring tale of his own family makes that very case.

Stephanie Mencimer

Reporter
Stephanie Mencimer is a staff reporter in Mother Jones' Washington bureau. For more of her stories, click here. You can also follow her on Twitter. RSS |