The Truth-O-Meter Says:
"A strong bipartisan majority" in the House of Representatives "voted to defund Obamacare."
Ted Cruz on Friday, September 20th, 2013 in a news release
Ted Cruz says 'a strong bipartisan majority' in the House of Representatives 'voted to defund Obamacare'
Share this story:
Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, has been the leading lawmaker in favor of using leverage on spending bills to force defunding or delays on Obamacare.
Where the showdown over a government shutdown is concerned, the blame game runs both ways.
Congress and the White House are at loggerheads over what to do with President Barack Obama’s health care law. Major aspects of the law are set to go live on Oct. 1, the same day as funding for the federal government runs out. But efforts to keep the funding flowing have floundered on the demand of some Republicans to defund or delay the law, while the president has refused to eliminate or pare back his signature legislative achievement.
We noticed two similar, but opposite, claims about how the parties broke on key votes in the conflict. Here, we will look at a claim by Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. In a separate fact-check, we will look at a claim by Obama.
After passage of a measure on Sept. 20, 2013, to fund the government without funding Obamacare, Cruz -- a leader of the pro-defunding side -- released a statement that said in part, "Today, the House of Representatives did what Washington pundits only a few weeks ago said was impossible: a strong bipartisan majority voted to defund Obamacare. This is a victory for House conservatives, and it is a victory for Speaker (John) Boehner and Republican leadership."
Was it accurate for Cruz to say that "a strong bipartisan majority" in the House of Representatives "voted to defund Obamacare"? We didn’t hear back from Cruz’s office, but we looked at the vote tallies ourselves.
On the final vote, the measure -- which paired continued funding for the government with a defunding of Obamacare -- passed by a 230-189 margin. But those 230 votes in favor broke down to 228 Republicans and just two Democrats, Reps. Mike McIntyre of North Carolina and Jim Matheson of Utah. (One Republican, Rep. Scott Rigell of Virginia, broke ranks and joined the Democrats.)
We have addressed claims of "bipartisanship" in the past and have generally been skeptical of a claim where a tiny fraction of a caucus serves as justification for the "bipartisan" label.
Norm Ornstein, a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, told us in 2011 that his definition would be "healthy numbers, not necessarily majorities, and not necessarily equally drawn, from both parties" -- a threshold hardly met in this case.
Several other experts we checked with for this fact-check agreed.
"I think a reasonable person would expect the threshold to be higher, particularly if the modifier ‘strong’ is applied," as Cruz included in his statement, said Roy T. Meyers, a political scientist at the University of Maryland-Baltimore County.
Donald Wolfensberger, director of the Congress Project at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars and a former Republican staff director of the House Rules Committee, felt similarly.
"Two Democrats, like two swallows, do not a bipartisan summer make," Wolfensberger said. "It's more like a false spring. Beauty and political truth are in the eye of the beholder. We all tend to see what we want to see."
Our ruling
Cruz said that "a strong bipartisan majority" in the House of Representatives "voted to defund Obamacare."
Even if you consider the overall 230-189 margin to be a "strong" victory for backers of the measure, it doesn’t qualify as "bipartisan" except in the most hyper-technical sense. Two Democrats out of the 190 who voted -- barely more than 1 percent of the party’s caucus -- joined Republicans in voting for the bill. In our book, that doesn’t qualify as much of a bipartisan action. We rate the claim False.
About this statement:
Published: Monday, September 30th, 2013 at 5:22 p.m.
Sources:
Ted Cruz, "Cruz: Fight to Save America from Obamacare is Only Just Beginning," Sept. 20, 2013
U.S. House of Representatives, roll call vote on a measure to make continuing appropriations for fiscal year 2014 and for other purposes, Sept. 20, 2013
PolitiFact, "Bipartisan support for 'cut, cap and balance,' John Boehner says," July 26, 2011
Email interview with Alan Abramowitz, Emory University political scientist, Sept. 30, 2013
Email interview with Larry Sabato, University of Virginia political scientist, Sept. 30, 2013
Email interview with Donald Wolfensberger, director of the Congress Project at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Sept. 30, 2013
Email interview with Roy T. Meyers, political scientist at the University of Maryland-Baltimore County, Sept. 30, 2013
No comments:
Post a Comment